American Pharoah at Stud, 2016–2026

In this article
  1. Keeneland September
  2. Sire Rankings
  3. Kentucky’s Class of 2016
  4. Dirt and Turf
  5. Japan
  6. Method and Sources

Provisional 2026 is a partial year · sale results through November 3, 2026 · sire lists through November 10 · Japanese race records through November 9

The sales, sire rankings and racing records behind American Pharoah: Big in Japan (But What Happened in America?), in one place. Five charts, each with its data, and the tables the article draws on.

American Pharoah entered stud at Ashford Stud in 2016 at $200,000 and stood in Kentucky through the 2025 season. He stands at the Japan Bloodhorse Breeders’ Association’s Shizunai Stallion Station in Hokkaido for 2026 and 2027. Every sale figure here counts ring sales only; every 2026 racing figure is a partial year and will change as the season runs.

6.10× → 0.76×

his Keeneland September median against the sale’s, 2018 and 2026

0.50×

his colts’ median against all colts sold this September; fillies 1.33×

16.2–33.4%

of his credited progeny earnings from races outside North America each year, 2019–2026

14.1%

JRA dirt win rate, seventh of 23 American sires; the other 36 combined 13.1%

218

mares bred in Japan in 2026 at ¥4,000,000 (about $25,300), the fourth-largest book there

Keeneland September

Figure 1 · Two steps down

His colts fell from four times the colt median to half of it; his fillies fell from seven times the filly median to between one and two times it

American Pharoah's Keeneland September median as a multiple of the median for his sex, colts and fillies, 2018 to 2026 Colts: 2018 4.58; 2019 3.64; 2020 4.22; 2021 2.14; 2022 2.00; 2023 2.50; 2024 0.88; 2025 0.56; 2026 0.50. Fillies: 2018 7.21; 2019 6.58; 2020 6.67; 2021 2.73; 2022 3.33; 2023 2.50; 2024 1.25; 2025 2.00; 2026 1.33. Multiple of the median for his sex 0× 2× 4× 6× 8× 1× = the median 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Fillies, 2018: 7.21 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2019: 6.58 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2020: 6.67 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2021: 2.73 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2022: 3.33 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2023: 2.50 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2024: 1.25 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2025: 2.00 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2026: 1.33 times the median for fillies Fillies 1.33× 7.21× Colts, 2018: 4.58 times the median for colts Colts, 2019: 3.64 times the median for colts Colts, 2020: 4.22 times the median for colts Colts, 2021: 2.14 times the median for colts Colts, 2022: 2.00 times the median for colts Colts, 2023: 2.50 times the median for colts Colts, 2024: 0.88 times the median for colts Colts, 2025: 0.56 times the median for colts Colts, 2026: 0.50 times the median for colts Colts 0.50× 4.58× American Pharoah's Keeneland September median as a multiple of the median for his sex, colts and fillies, 2018 to 2026 Colts: 2018 4.58; 2019 3.64; 2020 4.22; 2021 2.14; 2022 2.00; 2023 2.50; 2024 0.88; 2025 0.56; 2026 0.50. Fillies: 2018 7.21; 2019 6.58; 2020 6.67; 2021 2.73; 2022 3.33; 2023 2.50; 2024 1.25; 2025 2.00; 2026 1.33. Multiple of the median for his sex 0× 2× 4× 6× 8× 1× = the median ’18 ’19 ’20 ’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 ’25 ’26 Fillies, 2018: 7.21 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2019: 6.58 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2020: 6.67 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2021: 2.73 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2022: 3.33 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2023: 2.50 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2024: 1.25 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2025: 2.00 times the median for fillies Fillies, 2026: 1.33 times the median for fillies Fillies 1.33× Colts, 2018: 4.58 times the median for colts Colts, 2019: 3.64 times the median for colts Colts, 2020: 4.22 times the median for colts Colts, 2021: 2.14 times the median for colts Colts, 2022: 2.00 times the median for colts Colts, 2023: 2.50 times the median for colts Colts, 2024: 0.88 times the median for colts Colts, 2025: 0.56 times the median for colts Colts, 2026: 0.50 times the median for colts Colts 0.50×
American Pharoah’s yearlings sold in the ring at Keeneland’s September Yearling Sale, 2018 to 2026, horses-of-racing-age sessions excluded. Each line is his median for that sex divided by the median for all yearlings of that sex sold the same year; the dashed line marks parity. Medians are ring sales only: RNAs, post-sales and outs are excluded, and so are geldings and ridglings, which the results list separately from colts. His samples run from 8 colts sold in 2026 to 33 fillies in 2019.
Show the data
SaleConceived, feeHis soldHis medianSale medianMultipleHis colts soldHis colt medianAll coltsColt multipleHis fillies soldHis filly medianAll filliesFilly multiple
20182016, $200,00050$305,000$50,0006.1031$275,000$60,0004.5819$310,000$43,0007.21
20192017, Private62$225,000$47,0004.7929$200,000$55,0003.6433$250,000$38,0006.58
20202018, Private31$200,000$37,0005.4114$190,000$45,0004.2217$200,000$30,0006.67
20212019, $110,000 announced, then private40$150,000$65,0002.3118$150,000$70,0002.1422$150,000$55,0002.73
20222020, $175,00047$180,000$70,0002.5726$150,000$75,0002.0021$200,000$60,0003.33
20232021, $100,00041$150,000$67,0002.2418$187,500$75,0002.5023$150,000$60,0002.50
20242022, $80,00031$70,000$70,0001.0016$65,000$73,5000.8815$75,000$60,0001.25
20252023, $60,00023$85,000$80,0001.0612$50,000$90,0000.5611$140,000$70,0002.00
20262024, $50,00019$65,000$85,0000.768$47,500$95,0000.5011$100,000$75,0001.33

Table 1 · Seven figures, all female

Every American Pharoah sold for $1,000,000 or more since 2021 was a filly or mare

HorseSaleYearPrice
Yearling filly out of LetgomyechoKeeneland September2021$1,400,000
2-year-old filly out of Just ParkerOBS March2022$1,000,000
FabulousFasig-Tipton November2022$1,500,000
FlattermewithrosesFasig-Tipton November2023$2,000,000
Yearling filly out of Just LouiseKeeneland September2024$1,350,000
LonelilyFasig-Tipton November2024$1,200,000
KathynmarissaFasig-Tipton November2026$3,200,000
Hip 119, weanling filly out of Lady IreneKeeneland November2026$1,000,000
Public auction results at the Keeneland, Fasig-Tipton and OBS sales in our files, 2021 through November 3, 2026; private sales and RNAs excluded. The last seven-figure colt was the $1,250,000 colt out of Swingit at Fasig-Tipton’s Selected Yearlings Showcase in September 2020.

Sire Rankings

Figure 2 · Where the ranking came from

Roughly a sixth to a third of his money every year came from races outside North America

American Pharoah's progeny earnings by year, races in North America and races elsewhere, 2019 to 2026 2019: $2,267,229 in North America, $436,687 elsewhere, $2,703,916 in all; 2020: $3,874,300 in North America, $1,940,483 elsewhere, $5,814,783 in all; 2021: $7,344,927 in North America, $1,425,147 elsewhere, $8,770,074 in all; 2022: $8,461,551 in North America, $2,441,423 elsewhere, $10,902,974 in all; 2023: $9,543,816 in North America, $3,883,574 elsewhere, $13,427,390 in all; 2024: $9,108,576 in North America, $2,567,099 elsewhere, $11,675,675 in all; 2025: $8,216,926 in North America, $3,757,486 elsewhere, $11,974,412 in all; 2026: $9,087,757 in North America, $2,739,493 elsewhere, $11,827,250 in all. 2026 through November 9. Races in North America Races elsewhere $0M $2M $4M $6M $8M $10M $12M $14M 2019: $2,267,229 in North America, $436,687 elsewhere (16.2%), $2,703,916 in all 16% 2019 2020: $3,874,300 in North America, $1,940,483 elsewhere (33.4%), $5,814,783 in all 33% 2020 2021: $7,344,927 in North America, $1,425,147 elsewhere (16.3%), $8,770,074 in all 16% 2021 2022: $8,461,551 in North America, $2,441,423 elsewhere (22.4%), $10,902,974 in all 22% 2022 2023: $9,543,816 in North America, $3,883,574 elsewhere (28.9%), $13,427,390 in all 29% 2023 2024: $9,108,576 in North America, $2,567,099 elsewhere (22.0%), $11,675,675 in all 22% 2024 2025: $8,216,926 in North America, $3,757,486 elsewhere (31.4%), $11,974,412 in all 31% 2025 2026: $9,087,757 in North America, $2,739,493 elsewhere (23.2%), $11,827,250 in all 23% 2026 Label: share from races elsewhere American Pharoah's progeny earnings by year, races in North America and races elsewhere, 2019 to 2026 2019: $2,267,229 in North America, $436,687 elsewhere, $2,703,916 in all; 2020: $3,874,300 in North America, $1,940,483 elsewhere, $5,814,783 in all; 2021: $7,344,927 in North America, $1,425,147 elsewhere, $8,770,074 in all; 2022: $8,461,551 in North America, $2,441,423 elsewhere, $10,902,974 in all; 2023: $9,543,816 in North America, $3,883,574 elsewhere, $13,427,390 in all; 2024: $9,108,576 in North America, $2,567,099 elsewhere, $11,675,675 in all; 2025: $8,216,926 in North America, $3,757,486 elsewhere, $11,974,412 in all; 2026: $9,087,757 in North America, $2,739,493 elsewhere, $11,827,250 in all. 2026 through November 9. Races in North America Races elsewhere $0M $4M $8M $12M 2019: $2,267,229 in North America, $436,687 elsewhere (16.2%), $2,703,916 in all 16% ’19 2020: $3,874,300 in North America, $1,940,483 elsewhere (33.4%), $5,814,783 in all 33% ’20 2021: $7,344,927 in North America, $1,425,147 elsewhere (16.3%), $8,770,074 in all 16% ’21 2022: $8,461,551 in North America, $2,441,423 elsewhere (22.4%), $10,902,974 in all 22% ’22 2023: $9,543,816 in North America, $3,883,574 elsewhere (28.9%), $13,427,390 in all 29% ’23 2024: $9,108,576 in North America, $2,567,099 elsewhere (22.0%), $11,675,675 in all 22% ’24 2025: $8,216,926 in North America, $3,757,486 elsewhere (31.4%), $11,974,412 in all 31% ’25 2026: $9,087,757 in North America, $2,739,493 elsewhere (23.2%), $11,827,250 in all 23% ’26 Label: share from races elsewhere
American Pharoah’s progeny earnings by calendar year on BloodHorse’s leading-sire list by progeny earnings, which counts Northern Hemisphere runners wherever they race and credits Japanese earnings at 84 percent and Hong Kong earnings at 18 percent. The green segment is the same list filtered to races run in North America; the gray segment is the difference. 2026 is through November 9; on the list of November 10 his total is $11,855,786.
Show the data
YearStandard-list rankRunnersEarningsNorth American rankRunnersEarningsElsewhereShare elsewhereExtra runners
201912272$2,703,91613953$2,267,229$436,68716.2%19
202028169$5,814,78352127$3,874,300$1,940,48333.4%42
202116258$8,770,07423198$7,344,927$1,425,14716.3%60
202211299$10,902,97419225$8,461,551$2,441,42322.4%74
20236297$13,427,39016213$9,543,816$3,883,57428.9%84
202415317$11,675,67522211$9,108,576$2,567,09922.0%106
202516297$11,974,41227200$8,216,926$3,757,48631.4%97
2026 (to Nov. 9)14260$11,827,25019177$9,087,757$2,739,49323.2%83

Table 3 · Earnings per runner, North American racing

In the top third of sires with at least 150 North American runners in five of six years

YearNorth American runnersEarnings per runnerRank among sires with 150+ runners
2021198$37,09620 of 62
2022225$37,60726 of 67
2023213$44,80714 of 62
2024211$43,16917 of 61
2025200$41,08520 of 61
2026 (to Nov. 9)177$51,34311 of 53
BloodHorse leading-sire list by progeny earnings filtered to races run in North America. Rank is among sires with at least 150 North American runners that year. 2026 is through November 9.

Kentucky’s Class of 2016

Table 2 · Kentucky’s class of 2016, then and now

He stood for five times the next-highest fee; two classmates who started at $25,000 now rank above him

Stallion2016 farm2016 fee2016 mares2026 location2026 fee2026 mares2026 sire rank
by earnings
American PharoahAshford$200,000208Shizunai, Japan¥4,000,000
($25,300)
21814
ConstitutionWinStar$25,000172WinStar, Ky.$110,0001847
Liam’s MapLane’s End$25,000148Lane’s End, Ky.$50,0001699
TonalistLane’s End$30,000138Lane’s End, Ky.$10,000788
Honor CodeLane’s End$40,000144Yushun, Japan¥1,500,000
($9,500)
102150
Palace MaliceThree Chimneys$20,000158Darley Japan¥3,500,000
($22,100)
246121
Carpe DiemWinStar$25,000163LACER, La.$3,50057–
Advertised fees. Fees in Japan are in yen, include tax and are payable once the mare is confirmed in foal; dollar figures convert them at ¥158.23 to the dollar, the Federal Reserve’s rate for November 6, 2026, rounded to the nearest $100. Mares bred are from The Jockey Club’s Report of Mares Bred (2026 preliminary, reports received through November 9) and, for stallions in Japan, JBIS and the stallion stations; Japanese covers are outside the Jockey Club totals. Sire rank is the 2026 leading-sire list by progeny earnings, the standard list that counts each sire’s Northern Hemisphere runners wherever they race, with relocated sires included, read November 9; American Pharoah, Constitution and Liam’s Map hold the same places on the list of November 10. Carpe Diem is outside the 150 and appears on BloodHorse’s Southwest regional list. In 2026 American Pharoah stands at the JBBA’s Shizunai Stallion Station, Honor Code at Yushun Stallion Station, Palace Malice at the Darley Japan Stallion Complex and Carpe Diem at LACER at Aztec Equine in Louisiana.

Table 4 · Advertised fees by season

Constitution’s fee passed American Pharoah’s in 2022

Stallion20162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
American Pharoah$200,000PrivatePrivatePrivate ($110,000 announced)$175,000$100,000$80,000$60,000$50,000$45,000¥4,000,000
($25,300)
Constitution$25,000$25,000$25,000$15,000$40,000$85,000$85,000$110,000$110,000$110,000$110,000
Liam’s Map$25,000$25,000$25,000$20,000$35,000$30,000$40,000$40,000$40,000$40,000$50,000
Tonalist$30,000$30,000$20,000$15,000$15,000$12,500$10,000$10,000$10,000$10,000$10,000
Honor Code$40,000$40,000$40,000$40,000$30,000$20,000$20,000$20,000¥1,800,000
($11,400)
¥1,800,000
($11,400)
¥1,500,000
($9,500)
Palace Malice$20,000$20,000$20,000$25,000$25,000$20,000$12,500$7,500¥3,500,000
($22,100)
¥3,500,000
($22,100)
¥3,500,000
($22,100)
Carpe Diem$25,000$25,000$25,000$25,000$15,000$7,500$3,500$3,500$3,500$3,500$3,500
Advertised fees for the season named; fees in Japan are in yen, with dollars at ¥158.23 to the dollar, the Federal Reserve’s rate for November 6, 2026, rounded to the nearest $100. Ashford announced $110,000 for American Pharoah for 2019 and later listed the fee as private. 2027 fees announced so far: American Pharoah ¥4,000,000 (about $25,300), Constitution $110,000, Liam’s Map $80,000, Tonalist $5,000.

Table 5 · Mares bred by season

Constitution’s book jumped to 244 after his first runners; Tonalist’s fell to 7

Stallion20162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
American Pharoah208214182178153204145132161168218 (Japan)
Constitution17214311085244192187175167188184
Liam’s Map148158114133156176177157141157169
Tonalist13811512463122548711538127
Honor Code14415315413885294438152 (Japan)134 (Japan)102 (Japan)
Palace Malice158117659120714126262 (Japan)237 (Japan)246 (Japan)
Carpe Diem16314513313033115764573657
The Jockey Club’s Report of Mares Bred, North America, with 2026 preliminary (reports received through November 9); some totals include a few mares bred on Southern Hemisphere time. Seasons in Japan are from JBIS and the stallion stations and are outside the Jockey Club totals.

Dirt and Turf

Figure 3 · One sire, two surfaces

Bottom fifth of leading dirt sires by share of winners every year; top quarter of leading turf sires by earnings per runner in five of seven

American Pharoah's percentile among leading North American dirt sires by share of runners who won, and among leading turf sires by earnings per runner, 2020 to 2026 Dirt, share of runners who won: 2020 0th percentile; 2021 6th percentile; 2022 15th percentile; 2023 9th percentile; 2024 18th percentile; 2025 17th percentile; 2026 13th percentile. Turf, earnings per runner: 2020 84th percentile; 2021 74th percentile; 2022 55th percentile; 2023 89th percentile; 2024 88th percentile; 2025 77th percentile; 2026 96th percentile. Percentile among leading sires (100 = best) Top fifth Bottom fifth 0 20 40 60 80 100 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2020: 84th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2021: 74th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2022: 55th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2023: 89th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2024: 88th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2025: 77th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2026: 96th percentile by earnings per turf runner Turf, earnings per runner 2020: 0th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2021: 6th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2022: 15th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2023: 9th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2024: 18th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2025: 17th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2026: 13th percentile by share of dirt runners who won Dirt, share who won American Pharoah's percentile among leading North American dirt sires by share of runners who won, and among leading turf sires by earnings per runner, 2020 to 2026 Dirt, share of runners who won: 2020 0th percentile; 2021 6th percentile; 2022 15th percentile; 2023 9th percentile; 2024 18th percentile; 2025 17th percentile; 2026 13th percentile. Turf, earnings per runner: 2020 84th percentile; 2021 74th percentile; 2022 55th percentile; 2023 89th percentile; 2024 88th percentile; 2025 77th percentile; 2026 96th percentile. Percentile among leading sires (100 = best) Top fifth Bottom fifth 0 20 40 60 80 100 ’20 ’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 ’25 ’26 2020: 84th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2021: 74th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2022: 55th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2023: 89th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2024: 88th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2025: 77th percentile by earnings per turf runner 2026: 96th percentile by earnings per turf runner Turf 2020: 0th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2021: 6th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2022: 15th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2023: 9th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2024: 18th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2025: 17th percentile by share of dirt runners who won 2026: 13th percentile by share of dirt runners who won Dirt
BloodHorse leading-sire lists by progeny earnings, races run in North America only, the 150 leading sires on each surface each year. Percentile is the share of sires with at least 20 runners on that list who ranked below him: on dirt by winners as a share of runners, on turf by earnings per runner. 2026 is through November 9.
Show the data
YearDirt rankDirt runnersWinnersShare who wonMedian sirePercentileTurf rankTurf runnersTurf earningsPer runnerMedian sirePercentile
202084822226.8%43.1%01794$1,953,562$20,783$12,80084
2021471334735.3%47.5%610142$3,171,919$22,337$17,10274
2022311496140.9%47.7%1519137$2,551,738$18,626$17,14155
2023431495536.9%47.6%99137$4,235,015$30,913$16,82689
2024641315542.0%47.3%189142$4,895,573$34,476$17,29688
2025481164841.4%47.6%1719130$3,339,696$25,690$18,59277
2026 (to Nov. 9)67993838.4%47.0%135116$5,683,402$48,995$18,92396

Table 6 · Runners against their mares

Among leading sires with at least six crops racing, his runners trail his mares’ runners by other stallions by the widest margin, tied with Honor Code

Sire and dateAEIMares’ CIAEI minus CI
American Pharoah, November 8, 20201.712.98−1.27
American Pharoah, 20251.392.13−0.74
American Pharoah, November 20261.382.09−0.71
Honor Code, November 20261.071.78−0.71
Liam’s Map, November 20261.391.58−0.19
Constitution, November 20261.741.63+0.11
Tonalist, November 20261.711.23+0.48
BloodHorse Average-Earnings Index (AEI) and Comparable Index (CI), both lifetime figures. Among the 150 leading sires by AEI in November 2026, 84 have an AEI below their mares’ CI and the median shortfall is 0.045; American Pharoah’s 0.71 is tied with Honor Code’s for the largest among the 118 with at least six crops racing; only Charlatan (1.14) and Essential Quality (0.80), with two crops each, trail by more.

Japan

Table 7 · His runners in Japan

Of 237 wins in Japan, 221 came on dirt, 135 of them on the regional circuit

Circuit and surfaceStartsWinsWin rate
JRA dirt6098614.1%
JRA turf1491610.7%
JRA jumps700.0%
NAR (regional) dirt50813526.6%
All races in Japan1,27323718.6%
Every start in Japan by American Pharoah’s 102 runners there, from netkeiba, read November 9, 2026. A start is a race with a recorded finishing position; scratches, exclusions and five races in which the horse did not finish are left out. Starts abroad (Saudi Arabia, Dubai, the United States) are excluded. 74 of the 102 runners have won.

Figure 4 · Top third on rank

Seventh of 23 American sires on JRA dirt, a point above the other 36 combined

JRA dirt win rate, 2019 to 2026, for 23 American sires with at least 60 JRA dirt starts Into Mischief 18.5% (73 wins from 395 starts); Nyquist 17.5% (11 wins from 63 starts); Union Rags 17.5% (11 wins from 63 starts); Frosted 16.9% (13 wins from 77 starts); Arrogate 16.3% (28 wins from 172 starts); Malibu Moon 15.8% (16 wins from 101 starts); American Pharoah 14.1% (86 wins from 611 starts); Gun Runner 13.4% (27 wins from 202 starts); Justify 13.1% (36 wins from 275 starts); Uncle Mo 12.7% (23 wins from 181 starts); Liam’s Map 12.7% (13 wins from 102 starts); Tapit 12.0% (33 wins from 274 starts); Speightstown 11.8% (34 wins from 288 starts); Pioneerof the Nile 11.5% (15 wins from 130 starts); Distorted Humor 11.2% (11 wins from 98 starts); Quality Road 11.1% (15 wins from 135 starts); Kitten’s Joy 10.9% (7 wins from 64 starts); Constitution 10.5% (9 wins from 86 starts); War Front 10.5% (8 wins from 76 starts); Curlin 10.1% (16 wins from 159 starts); Bernardini 10.0% (7 wins from 70 starts); Practical Joke 8.9% (11 wins from 123 starts); Medaglia d’Oro 6.9% (6 wins from 87 starts). The 36 other American sires combined: 13.1%. JRA dirt wins per start 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 36 others: 13.1% Into Mischief Into Mischief: 18.5%, 73 wins from 395 JRA dirt starts 18.5% Nyquist Nyquist: 17.5%, 11 wins from 63 JRA dirt starts 17.5% Union Rags Union Rags: 17.5%, 11 wins from 63 JRA dirt starts 17.5% Frosted Frosted: 16.9%, 13 wins from 77 JRA dirt starts 16.9% Arrogate Arrogate: 16.3%, 28 wins from 172 JRA dirt starts 16.3% Malibu Moon Malibu Moon: 15.8%, 16 wins from 101 JRA dirt starts 15.8% American Pharoah American Pharoah: 14.1%, 86 wins from 611 JRA dirt starts 14.1% Gun Runner Gun Runner: 13.4%, 27 wins from 202 JRA dirt starts 13.4% Justify Justify: 13.1%, 36 wins from 275 JRA dirt starts 13.1% Uncle Mo Uncle Mo: 12.7%, 23 wins from 181 JRA dirt starts 12.7% Liam’s Map Liam’s Map: 12.7%, 13 wins from 102 JRA dirt starts 12.7% Tapit Tapit: 12.0%, 33 wins from 274 JRA dirt starts 12.0% Speightstown Speightstown: 11.8%, 34 wins from 288 JRA dirt starts 11.8% Pioneerof the Nile Pioneerof the Nile: 11.5%, 15 wins from 130 JRA dirt starts 11.5% Distorted Humor Distorted Humor: 11.2%, 11 wins from 98 JRA dirt starts 11.2% Quality Road Quality Road: 11.1%, 15 wins from 135 JRA dirt starts 11.1% Kitten’s Joy Kitten’s Joy: 10.9%, 7 wins from 64 JRA dirt starts 10.9% Constitution Constitution: 10.5%, 9 wins from 86 JRA dirt starts 10.5% War Front War Front: 10.5%, 8 wins from 76 JRA dirt starts 10.5% Curlin Curlin: 10.1%, 16 wins from 159 JRA dirt starts 10.1% Bernardini Bernardini: 10.0%, 7 wins from 70 JRA dirt starts 10.0% Practical Joke Practical Joke: 8.9%, 11 wins from 123 JRA dirt starts 8.9% Medaglia d’Oro Medaglia d’Oro: 6.9%, 6 wins from 87 JRA dirt starts 6.9% JRA dirt win rate, 2019 to 2026, for 23 American sires with at least 60 JRA dirt starts Into Mischief 18.5% (73 wins from 395 starts); Nyquist 17.5% (11 wins from 63 starts); Union Rags 17.5% (11 wins from 63 starts); Frosted 16.9% (13 wins from 77 starts); Arrogate 16.3% (28 wins from 172 starts); Malibu Moon 15.8% (16 wins from 101 starts); American Pharoah 14.1% (86 wins from 611 starts); Gun Runner 13.4% (27 wins from 202 starts); Justify 13.1% (36 wins from 275 starts); Uncle Mo 12.7% (23 wins from 181 starts); Liam’s Map 12.7% (13 wins from 102 starts); Tapit 12.0% (33 wins from 274 starts); Speightstown 11.8% (34 wins from 288 starts); Pioneerof the Nile 11.5% (15 wins from 130 starts); Distorted Humor 11.2% (11 wins from 98 starts); Quality Road 11.1% (15 wins from 135 starts); Kitten’s Joy 10.9% (7 wins from 64 starts); Constitution 10.5% (9 wins from 86 starts); War Front 10.5% (8 wins from 76 starts); Curlin 10.1% (16 wins from 159 starts); Bernardini 10.0% (7 wins from 70 starts); Practical Joke 8.9% (11 wins from 123 starts); Medaglia d’Oro 6.9% (6 wins from 87 starts). The 36 other American sires combined: 13.1%. JRA dirt wins per start 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 36 others: 13.1% Into Mischief Into Mischief: 18.5%, 73 wins from 395 JRA dirt starts 18.5% Nyquist Nyquist: 17.5%, 11 wins from 63 JRA dirt starts 17.5% Union Rags Union Rags: 17.5%, 11 wins from 63 JRA dirt starts 17.5% Frosted Frosted: 16.9%, 13 wins from 77 JRA dirt starts 16.9% Arrogate Arrogate: 16.3%, 28 wins from 172 JRA dirt starts 16.3% Malibu Moon Malibu Moon: 15.8%, 16 wins from 101 JRA dirt starts 15.8% American Pharoah American Pharoah: 14.1%, 86 wins from 611 JRA dirt starts 14.1% Gun Runner Gun Runner: 13.4%, 27 wins from 202 JRA dirt starts 13.4% Justify Justify: 13.1%, 36 wins from 275 JRA dirt starts 13.1% Uncle Mo Uncle Mo: 12.7%, 23 wins from 181 JRA dirt starts 12.7% Liam’s Map Liam’s Map: 12.7%, 13 wins from 102 JRA dirt starts 12.7% Tapit Tapit: 12.0%, 33 wins from 274 JRA dirt starts 12.0% Speightstown Speightstown: 11.8%, 34 wins from 288 JRA dirt starts 11.8% Pioneerof the Nile Pioneerof the Nile: 11.5%, 15 wins from 130 JRA dirt starts 11.5% Distorted Humor Distorted Humor: 11.2%, 11 wins from 98 JRA dirt starts 11.2% Quality Road Quality Road: 11.1%, 15 wins from 135 JRA dirt starts 11.1% Kitten’s Joy Kitten’s Joy: 10.9%, 7 wins from 64 JRA dirt starts 10.9% Constitution Constitution: 10.5%, 9 wins from 86 JRA dirt starts 10.5% War Front War Front: 10.5%, 8 wins from 76 JRA dirt starts 10.5% Curlin Curlin: 10.1%, 16 wins from 159 JRA dirt starts 10.1% Bernardini Bernardini: 10.0%, 7 wins from 70 JRA dirt starts 10.0% Practical Joke Practical Joke: 8.9%, 11 wins from 123 JRA dirt starts 8.9% Medaglia d’Oro Medaglia d’Oro: 6.9%, 6 wins from 87 JRA dirt starts 6.9%
JRA races only, 2019 through November 9, 2026, from netkeiba’s sire statistics: wins divided by starts on dirt for the 23 American-based sires with at least 60 JRA dirt starts. Runners foaled in Japan from imported mares count on both sides. The dashed line is the combined rate for the 36 other American-based sires in our comparison, 478 wins from 3,660 starts. Sires that stood in Japan are excluded. Not adjusted for field size or class.
Show the data
RankSireDirt winsDirt startsDirt win rateTurf winsTurf startsTurf win rateJRA graded winsCareer JRA runners
1Into Mischief7339518.5%8839.6%048
2Nyquist116317.5%080.0%012
3Union Rags116317.5%0110.0%012
4Frosted137716.9%146720.9%215
5Arrogate2817216.3%21513.3%018
6Malibu Moon1610115.8%0130.0%029
7American Pharoah8661114.1%1615010.7%699
8Gun Runner2720213.4%2395.1%025
9Justify3627513.1%1462.2%044
10Uncle Mo2318112.7%64214.3%035
11Liam’s Map1310212.7%1254.0%015
12Tapit3327412.0%4685.9%048
13Speightstown3428811.8%129912.1%253
14Pioneerof the Nile1513011.5%0120.0%017
15Distorted Humor119811.2%040.0%037
16Quality Road1513511.1%0130.0%018
17Kitten’s Joy76410.9%98510.6%231
18Constitution98610.5%32512.0%012
19War Front87610.5%75712.3%018
20Curlin1615910.1%0210.0%029
21Bernardini77010.0%21711.8%038
22Practical Joke111238.9%5608.3%015
23Medaglia d’Oro6876.9%4715.6%045
The 36 other American sires4783,66013.1%1121,08710.3%10

Figure 5 · American dirt does not predict Japanese sand

A sire’s record on American dirt says little about his record on Japanese dirt

North American dirt winners per runner against JRA dirt wins per start, 22 American sires Kitten’s Joy: 32.4% of North American dirt runners won, 10.9% of JRA dirt starts won; American Pharoah: 38.0% of North American dirt runners won, 14.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Justify: 34.9% of North American dirt runners won, 13.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Medaglia d’Oro: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won, 6.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Pioneerof the Nile: 41.9% of North American dirt runners won, 11.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Liam’s Map: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won, 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won; Uncle Mo: 43.4% of North American dirt runners won, 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won; Constitution: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won, 10.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Quality Road: 44.0% of North American dirt runners won, 11.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Speightstown: 50.6% of North American dirt runners won, 11.8% of JRA dirt starts won; Distorted Humor: 45.4% of North American dirt runners won, 11.2% of JRA dirt starts won; Nyquist: 41.2% of North American dirt runners won, 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Malibu Moon: 47.7% of North American dirt runners won, 15.8% of JRA dirt starts won; Frosted: 44.9% of North American dirt runners won, 16.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Tapit: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won, 12.0% of JRA dirt starts won; Into Mischief: 45.8% of North American dirt runners won, 18.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Bernardini: 43.0% of North American dirt runners won, 10.0% of JRA dirt starts won; Practical Joke: 48.2% of North American dirt runners won, 8.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Curlin: 46.7% of North American dirt runners won, 10.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Union Rags: 44.2% of North American dirt runners won, 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Arrogate: 49.7% of North American dirt runners won, 16.3% of JRA dirt starts won; Gun Runner: 48.6% of North American dirt runners won, 13.4% of JRA dirt starts won. Correlation 0.19. 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20% 30% 32% 34% 36% 38% 40% 42% 44% 46% 48% 50% 52% Share of North American dirt runners who won JRA dirt wins per start Kitten’s Joy: 32.4% of North American dirt runners won; 10.9% of JRA dirt starts won Kitten’s Joy Justify: 34.9% of North American dirt runners won; 13.1% of JRA dirt starts won Medaglia d’Oro: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won; 6.9% of JRA dirt starts won Medaglia d’Oro Pioneerof the Nile: 41.9% of North American dirt runners won; 11.5% of JRA dirt starts won Liam’s Map: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won; 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won Uncle Mo: 43.4% of North American dirt runners won; 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won Constitution: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won; 10.5% of JRA dirt starts won Quality Road: 44.0% of North American dirt runners won; 11.1% of JRA dirt starts won Speightstown: 50.6% of North American dirt runners won; 11.8% of JRA dirt starts won Speightstown Distorted Humor: 45.4% of North American dirt runners won; 11.2% of JRA dirt starts won Nyquist: 41.2% of North American dirt runners won; 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won Nyquist Malibu Moon: 47.7% of North American dirt runners won; 15.8% of JRA dirt starts won Frosted: 44.9% of North American dirt runners won; 16.9% of JRA dirt starts won Tapit: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won; 12.0% of JRA dirt starts won Tapit Into Mischief: 45.8% of North American dirt runners won; 18.5% of JRA dirt starts won Into Mischief Bernardini: 43.0% of North American dirt runners won; 10.0% of JRA dirt starts won Practical Joke: 48.2% of North American dirt runners won; 8.9% of JRA dirt starts won Curlin: 46.7% of North American dirt runners won; 10.1% of JRA dirt starts won Union Rags: 44.2% of North American dirt runners won; 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won Arrogate: 49.7% of North American dirt runners won; 16.3% of JRA dirt starts won Gun Runner: 48.6% of North American dirt runners won; 13.4% of JRA dirt starts won Gun Runner American Pharoah: 38.0% of North American dirt runners won; 14.1% of JRA dirt starts won American Pharoah Correlation: 0.19 North American dirt winners per runner against JRA dirt wins per start, 22 American sires Kitten’s Joy: 32.4% of North American dirt runners won, 10.9% of JRA dirt starts won; American Pharoah: 38.0% of North American dirt runners won, 14.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Justify: 34.9% of North American dirt runners won, 13.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Medaglia d’Oro: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won, 6.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Pioneerof the Nile: 41.9% of North American dirt runners won, 11.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Liam’s Map: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won, 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won; Uncle Mo: 43.4% of North American dirt runners won, 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won; Constitution: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won, 10.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Quality Road: 44.0% of North American dirt runners won, 11.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Speightstown: 50.6% of North American dirt runners won, 11.8% of JRA dirt starts won; Distorted Humor: 45.4% of North American dirt runners won, 11.2% of JRA dirt starts won; Nyquist: 41.2% of North American dirt runners won, 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Malibu Moon: 47.7% of North American dirt runners won, 15.8% of JRA dirt starts won; Frosted: 44.9% of North American dirt runners won, 16.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Tapit: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won, 12.0% of JRA dirt starts won; Into Mischief: 45.8% of North American dirt runners won, 18.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Bernardini: 43.0% of North American dirt runners won, 10.0% of JRA dirt starts won; Practical Joke: 48.2% of North American dirt runners won, 8.9% of JRA dirt starts won; Curlin: 46.7% of North American dirt runners won, 10.1% of JRA dirt starts won; Union Rags: 44.2% of North American dirt runners won, 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won; Arrogate: 49.7% of North American dirt runners won, 16.3% of JRA dirt starts won; Gun Runner: 48.6% of North American dirt runners won, 13.4% of JRA dirt starts won. Correlation 0.19. 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20% 30% 34% 38% 42% 46% 50% NA dirt runners who won JRA dirt wins per start Kitten’s Joy: 32.4% of North American dirt runners won; 10.9% of JRA dirt starts won Justify: 34.9% of North American dirt runners won; 13.1% of JRA dirt starts won Medaglia d’Oro: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won; 6.9% of JRA dirt starts won Pioneerof the Nile: 41.9% of North American dirt runners won; 11.5% of JRA dirt starts won Liam’s Map: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won; 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won Uncle Mo: 43.4% of North American dirt runners won; 12.7% of JRA dirt starts won Constitution: 41.6% of North American dirt runners won; 10.5% of JRA dirt starts won Quality Road: 44.0% of North American dirt runners won; 11.1% of JRA dirt starts won Speightstown: 50.6% of North American dirt runners won; 11.8% of JRA dirt starts won Distorted Humor: 45.4% of North American dirt runners won; 11.2% of JRA dirt starts won Nyquist: 41.2% of North American dirt runners won; 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won Nyquist Malibu Moon: 47.7% of North American dirt runners won; 15.8% of JRA dirt starts won Frosted: 44.9% of North American dirt runners won; 16.9% of JRA dirt starts won Tapit: 39.6% of North American dirt runners won; 12.0% of JRA dirt starts won Tapit Into Mischief: 45.8% of North American dirt runners won; 18.5% of JRA dirt starts won Bernardini: 43.0% of North American dirt runners won; 10.0% of JRA dirt starts won Practical Joke: 48.2% of North American dirt runners won; 8.9% of JRA dirt starts won Curlin: 46.7% of North American dirt runners won; 10.1% of JRA dirt starts won Union Rags: 44.2% of North American dirt runners won; 17.5% of JRA dirt starts won Arrogate: 49.7% of North American dirt runners won; 16.3% of JRA dirt starts won Gun Runner: 48.6% of North American dirt runners won; 13.4% of JRA dirt starts won American Pharoah: 38.0% of North American dirt runners won; 14.1% of JRA dirt starts won American Pharoah Correlation: 0.19
Horizontal: winners as a share of runners on North American dirt, pooled across the years from 2019 through November 9, 2026 in which each sire ranked among the 150 leading dirt sires. Vertical: JRA dirt wins per start over the same period. War Front, with one year on the dirt list, is excluded and listed in the data. Correlation across the 22 sires: 0.19.
Show the data
SireYears on the dirt listDirt runner-seasonsShare who wonMedian dirt percentileTurf share of NA moneyJRA dirt win rate
War Front (excluded: one dirt-list year)14526.7%188.8%10.5%
Kitten’s Joy454332.4%183.0%10.9%
American Pharoah785938.0%1351.9%14.1%
Justify543834.9%346.1%13.1%
Medaglia d’Oro884939.6%1940.8%6.9%
Pioneerof the Nile562141.9%2139.5%11.5%
Liam’s Map71,09241.6%2637.6%12.7%
Uncle Mo81,60043.4%3034.2%12.7%
Constitution81,34741.6%2031.9%10.5%
Quality Road81,29044.0%2431.0%11.1%
Speightstown81,02950.6%7529.0%11.8%
Distorted Humor777745.4%5328.5%11.2%
Nyquist71,00241.2%1524.6%17.5%
Malibu Moon71,27147.7%5322.5%15.8%
Frosted61,01344.9%2821.6%16.9%
Tapit81,24239.6%1120.8%12.0%
Into Mischief82,67145.8%3718.7%18.5%
Bernardini71,00343.0%2216.5%10.0%
Practical Joke61,27648.2%3913.8%8.9%
Curlin81,54646.7%4511.6%10.1%
Union Rags81,50144.2%278.5%17.5%
Arrogate332649.7%547.0%16.3%
Gun Runner61,03848.6%736.3%13.4%

Method and Sources

How the figures are built

Keeneland September figures come from Keeneland’s official results files for 2018 through 2026, horses-of-racing-age sessions excluded. Offered is sold plus RNA plus post-sale. Medians count horses sold in the ring only, so RNAs, post-sales and outs are excluded; the colt median counts horses catalogued as colts, and geldings and ridglings are left out of both sexes. Each multiple divides American Pharoah’s median by the median for all yearlings, or all of the same sex, sold that year. The season and advertised fee at conception are for the crop sold that September.

Sire rankings are BloodHorse’s leading sires by progeny earnings. The standard list counts Northern Hemisphere runners wherever they race and credits Japanese earnings at 84 percent and Hong Kong earnings at 18 percent; the North American figures use the same list filtered to races run in North America, and races elsewhere are the difference. Surface lists take the 150 leading sires on each surface by earnings in North America; percentiles are the share of sires with at least 20 runners on the list who ranked below him. Lists were read November 9, 2026, except the standard-list ranks for American Pharoah, Constitution and Liam’s Map, which match the list of November 10.

Japanese figures come from netkeiba. The race-by-race file covers all 102 of his runners in Japan; JRA figures by sire come from netkeiba’s sire statistics, 2019 through November 9, 2026, for 37 American-based sires whose runners race in Japan, excluding sires that stood in Japan. The surface comparison uses the 23 with at least 60 JRA dirt starts and measures North American dirt by winners per runner, pooled over the years each sire ranked among the 150 leading dirt sires. Fees and booking terms in Japan are from the JBBA’s stallion schedules and notices; the 2026 book of 218 is the JBBA’s count. Class-of-2016 fees are from farm fee pages and Racing Post; mares bred are from The Jockey Club’s Report of Mares Bred and, for Japan, JBIS and the stallion stations.

Other definitions used in the article. The 2023 rank without the Saudi Cup check subtracts Cafe Pharoah’s $2,000,000 from American Pharoah’s total and re-ranks it on the same list. Crop figures use BloodHorse’s lists of sires of 3-year-olds, North American racing. Betting-market expectations use 0.8 divided by decimal win odds. The dam-sire comparison classes Galileo, Frankel, High Chaparral, Teofilo, Camelot, Invincible Spirit, Kingman, Victoire Pisa, Heart’s Cry, Fastnet Rock, Kitten’s Joy and War Front as turf sires. Group 1 winners and his race record are from the JBBA’s stallion notice of October 10, 2025, plus Kathynmarissa. The 2026 book of 218 is the JBBA’s count as reported by Sponichi on June 26, 2026, which is also the source of Shigeki Yusa’s comments (translated from the Japanese); the covering ranking and the JRHA’s observations are from its “馬産地往来” column of October 25, 2026; Japanese fee rankings are from a published compilation of the stallion stations’ announcements. Kathynmarissa’s purchase and Shingo Hashimoto’s comments are from BloodHorse’s and the Paulick Report’s Fasig-Tipton November reports of November 2, 2026; Japanese buyers’ earlier efforts to buy him and his planned return are from the Daily Racing Form, June 26, 2026. AEI and CI are lifetime figures for the 150 leading sires by AEI with at least 150 named foals of racing age; crops counted are crops of racing age. Yen figures are converted at ¥158.23 to the dollar, the Federal Reserve’s rate for November 6, 2026. 2027 fees for Liam’s Map, Tonalist and Constitution are as announced by the farms and listed in the sire rankings of November 10, 2026.

Sources: Keeneland (September Yearling Sale and November Breeding Stock Sale results), Fasig-Tipton and OBS (sale results), BloodHorse (leading sires by progeny earnings; AEI and Comparable Index), The Jockey Club (Report of Mares Bred), netkeiba (race results and sire statistics), Japan Bloodhorse Breeders’ Association (October 2025 notice, booking terms, fee schedule), Japan Racing Horse Association (“今春の種付頭数がまとまる,” October 25, 2026), Coolmore (2026 season, 2027 season), TrueNicks (American Pharoah to remain at stud in Japan in 2027), Racing Post (fee unchanged for a second season in Japan), Maeda, Hanada and Oikawa, Journal of Equine Science 27: 81 (2016). The analysis is in American Pharoah: Big in Japan (But What Happened in America?).