Keeneland September 2026 · Sire Analysis

What a Record September Says About the Commercial Sire Market

Keeneland September is a commercial referendum on the sire market. This year the incumbents held their ground, a few challengers moved closer, Yaupon forced his way into elite company, and the money became even more concentrated at the top.

In this article
  1. Half the money went to 18 percent of the horses
  2. Gun Runner and Not This Time are getting awfully close
  3. Into Mischief did it with 40 horses
  4. Nyquist was the last "cheap seat" in the top five
  5. Flightline and Life Is Good
  6. Uncle Mo, one last time
  7. Justify remains Justify
  8. Yaupon did something nobody else in the top 10 did
  9. Farther down the fee table
  10. A few smaller signals
  11. Who actually captured the move?
  12. What September said about the sire market

One of my favorite things about Keeneland September is that it serves as a commercial referendum on the sire market. By the end of the sale, nearly every important commercial stallion has had his turn in front of buyers. We get to see how firmly the incumbents still control the market, whether a younger sire is moving into their territory, who has been re-rated, who suddenly has momentum and where buyers have become more selective.

It is also a good place to separate reputation from what people are actually willing to pay.

Gun Runner again generated more money than any other sire, although Not This Time came awfully close. Into Mischief needed only 40 sales to produce more than $30 million. Nyquist put together one of the best combinations of price and liquidity in the sale. Flightline and Life Is Good, who entered stud the same year, produced very different yearling markets. Justify remained expensive and unusually selective.

And then there was Yaupon. His yearlings were conceived on a $25,000 fee, yet he ended September ninth by gross on a list otherwise populated by stallions who stood for at least $85,000.

The concentration at the top itself was not surprising. Book 1 has been moving toward a smaller group of commercially elite sires for years, and when Gun Runners, Into Mischiefs and Not This Times are routinely selling for those kinds of prices, those sire groups are going to own a disproportionate amount of gross.

The degree of concentration was still worth looking at. The top 10 sires accounted for $273.7 million, or 49 percent of all reported gross, from only 544 of the 3,033 reported sales.


Half the money went to 18 percent of the horses

Using the same reported-sales basis, the top 10 accounted for 46.5 percent of gross in 2024 and 43.5 percent last year. This year they reached 49 percent.

Top 10 sires by gross, share of the Keeneland September Yearling Sale
YearTop 10 sire grossTotal sale grossTop 10 share of grossTop 10 share of horses sold
2024$199.0M$427.8M46.5%19.7%
2025$231.3M$531.5M43.5%15.9%
2026$273.7M$558.3M49.0%17.9%

Reported sales, including identifiable post-sale transactions. Total sale gross uses Keeneland's final reported figures.

What stands out is what happened underneath the percentage. Keeneland's reported gross increased by about $26.8 million from 2025. The top 10 sire groups increased by about $42.4 million. Taken together, every sire outside that group generated roughly $15.6 million less gross than a year ago.

It was not simply a matter of the leading sires supplying more horses. In 2024 the top 10 represented a larger share of reported sales than they did this year and still captured a smaller share of the money.

The million-dollar market was even more concentrated. Seventy yearlings brought at least $1 million, and 66 were by the 10 sires below. The top five alone produced 54 of the 70 million-dollar horses and $176.6 million in gross, almost 32 percent of the entire sale.

Top 10 sires by reported gross, Keeneland September 2026
RankSire2024 feeSoldClearanceAverageMedianGross$1M+
1Gun Runner$250,0005785.1%$766K$525K$43.67M15
2Not This Time$150,0005686.2%$730K$600K$40.87M12
3Nyquist$85,0005989.4%$526K$400K$31.02M8
4Flightline$150,0005281.3%$594K$468K$30.90M8
5Into Mischief$250,0004078.4%$753K$613K$30.11M11
6Life Is Good$85,0007094.6%$348K$300K$24.39M2
7Uncle Mo$150,0006287.3%$385K$300K$23.88M4
8Justify$200,0004971.0%$417K$310K$20.44M3
9Yaupon$25,0005787.7%$258K$225K$14.69M0
10Good Magic$125,0004279.2%$327K$220K$13.73M3

Reported sales, including identifiable post-sale transactions. Clearance is reported sales divided by horses offered, excluding withdrawals. The 2024 fee is the advertised fee for the breeding season that produced these yearlings.

Gross naturally rewards supply, so I would not read this as a ranking of the 10 best sire performances. Good Magic, for example, finished tenth with 42 sales, a $220,000 median and $13.7 million in gross. There is not much mystery there. His commercial level is pretty well established by now.

There is another lag in all of these numbers that is easy to overlook. These yearlings were conceived in 2024. They reflect what a stallion cost then, how breeders viewed him then and the kind of mares he was attracting then.

I do not have a complete quality profile for every mare in those books. The best proxy I have is the public market for mares sold in foal to each sire in 2024. It is imperfect because it includes only mares that came to auction, and the pregnancy itself is part of the mare's value. I am using it only as a rough picture of the commercial environment around the book. In a few cases the differences are large enough to add something useful.


Gun Runner and Not This Time are getting awfully close

Gun Runner led the sale again. Fifty-seven reported sales generated $43.7 million, 15 brought at least $1 million, his average was $766,000 and his median $525,000.

The distribution matters. Twenty-nine Book 1 Gun Runners sold at a $700,000 median. Twenty more sold in Book 2 at $437,500, and seven in Book 3 at $400,000. There were 67 offered in all, so buyers were hardly dealing with a scarce product.

Hands On History: Gun Runner at Three Chimneys Farm.

Not This Time finished less than $3 million behind him. Fifty-six sold for $40.9 million, with a higher median at $600,000, slightly better clearance at 86.2 percent and 12 seven-figure yearlings.

He was also doing this from a very different 2024 starting point. Not This Time stood for $150,000 when these horses were conceived, compared with $250,000 for Gun Runner. His fee went to $175,000 in 2025 and is $250,000 this year. He bred 192 mares in 2024 and 214 last year.

Even the public mare market looked different. Mares sold in foal to Gun Runner in 2024 averaged about $965,000. Those carrying Not This Time foals averaged about $443,000. I would not call that a comparison of mare quality, but it gives some sense of the commercial populations behind the two crops.

Gun Runner has been the benchmark at this sale for several years. Not This Time has now gotten close enough that the comparison is unavoidable.


Into Mischief did it with 40 horses

Into Mischief finished fifth by gross, which sounds almost ordinary until you realize only 40 horses accounted for the $30.1 million.

His $612,500 median was the highest among the top 10, and 11 of those 40 yearlings brought at least $1 million. All 51 offered Into Mischiefs were in Books 1 through 3. Fifteen Book 1 sales produced an $825,000 median, 16 in Book 2 had a $587,500 median and nine more sold in Book 3 at $300,000.

The 78.4 percent clearance rate was lower than Gun Runner, Not This Time and Nyquist. Buyers were still making distinctions. But more than one in four of the horses who sold brought seven figures.

Into Mischief was also working with the most expensive commercial mare population in this group by a wide margin. He bred 193 mares in 2024, and mares sold in foal to him that year averaged about $1.41 million.

That does not diminish the result. Attracting mares like that is part of what a stallion earns. It does matter when we compare him later with a sire such as Yaupon, because the two crops started from completely different places.


Nyquist was the last "cheap seat" in the top five

I have probably been guilty of describing Nyquist as quietly doing this or quietly doing that for too long. There was not much quiet about this sale.

Nyquist, a bay stallion, stands in profile on the grass while a handler in a Darley shirt holds his lead.
Nyquist. Photo courtesy of Darley.

Fifty-nine yearlings sold for $31 million at a $400,000 median, eight brought at least $1 million and 89.4 percent of those offered eventually had reported buyers. Fourteen Book 1 sales produced a $737,500 median, 24 sold in Book 2 at $430,000 and another 16 sold in Book 3 at $240,000.

That last part is worth keeping in mind when looking at his clearance. This was overwhelmingly a Books 1 through 3 population. He was exceptionally liquid within a very good group of yearlings.

These horses were conceived on an $85,000 fee. Nyquist now stands for $175,000, and our broader yearling data had his 2025 median at $300,000. The gap between what he cost and what his yearlings sold for used to look much wider than it does today.

That is probably as good a sign as any that the market has stopped treating him like an emerging commercial sire.


Flightline and Life Is Good

Flightline and Life Is Good entered stud in the same year, and their second yearling crops produced one of the more interesting comparisons in the sale.

Flightline sold 52 of 64 offered for $30.9 million at a $467,500 median. Eight brought at least $1 million. Eighteen Book 1 sales had a $762,500 median, another 18 in Book 2 had a $442,500 median and 15 sold in Book 3 at $320,000.

His fee has come down from $150,000 when these horses were conceived to $125,000 this year, but the better yearlings were still trading at elite prices.

Life Is Good got there differently. Seventy of 74 offered eventually sold, the best clearance rate among the top 10 at 94.6 percent. Only two reached $1 million, but 50 of 53 offered in Books 1 through 3 found reported buyers at a combined $400,000 median.

What interested me more was what happened after Book 3. Twenty of 21 Life Is Goods offered in Books 4 through 6 sold, with a $177,500 median. Buyers kept taking them even as the catalog moved into a very different class of horse.

His fee has moved from $85,000 in 2024 to $75,000 last year and $60,000 this year. The September yearling market, at least this time around, looked considerably more comfortable with him than that fee trajectory might suggest.

The racetrack will answer the more important questions. As yearling sires, though, Flightline and Life Is Good are already producing very different markets.


Uncle Mo, one last time

This was the final September yearling crop for Uncle Mo. Sixty-two sold for $23.9 million at a $300,000 median with 87.3 percent clearance, and four brought at least $1 million.

The market held together well behind Book 1. Twenty Book 1 yearlings sold at a $475,000 median, 22 in Book 2 at $325,000 and 10 in Book 3 at $185,000. All six offered in Book 4 sold, along with four of five in Book 5.

That breadth seems appropriate for Uncle Mo. His commercial appeal was never confined to one type of horse. He could give the market a dirt colt, a turf horse, a filly, a future stallion or simply a physical somebody wanted to own.

His last September crop looked a lot like the market he spent years building.


Justify remains Justify

Forty-nine Justifys generated $20.4 million in reported sales at a $310,000 median, and three brought at least $1 million. The other number is 71 percent clearance, by far the lowest among the top 10.

This was not something created by late-book horses. Thirty-one were offered in Book 1 and 21 sold. Twenty-nine were offered in Book 2 and 19 sold. All six offered in Book 3 sold.

We have seen enough of this now that I am reluctant to dismiss it as normal auction variance. Buyers will pay a lot for the Justifys they want and seem perfectly comfortable passing on the others.

There was substantial support behind this crop as well. Justify covered 285 mares in 2024, the largest book among the top 10, and mares sold in foal to him that year averaged about $613,000.

The international racing record is established. The stallion reputation is established. Yet his yearling market continues to make unusually sharp distinctions from horse to horse.


Yaupon did something nobody else in the top 10 did

The other nine top-10 sires stood for at least $85,000 when these yearlings were conceived. Yaupon stood for $25,000.

Yaupon, a dark bay stallion, gallops across his paddock inside a black plank fence.
Yaupon. Photo courtesy of Spendthrift Farm.

He sold 57 yearlings for $14.7 million at a $225,000 median and 87.7 percent clearance, without a million-dollar horse or a reported Book 1 sale. Thirteen sold in Book 2 at a $310,000 median, 21 in Book 3 at $225,000, 18 in Book 4 at $200,000 and five in Book 5 at $120,000.

That is the part of the result I like most. Books 2 through 4 accounted for 52 Yaupon sales and more than $14 million. He reached the top 10 by filling up the middle of the catalog rather than relying on a few horses at the very front.

He also covered 197 mares in 2024, so this was not a tiny crop creating a misleading result. What was different was the commercial level around him at the time. Mares sold in foal to Yaupon during 2024 averaged about $67,000. For comparison, the public averages were roughly $1.41 million for Into Mischief, $965,000 for Gun Runner, $613,000 for Justify and $443,000 for Not This Time.

Those numbers are not mare-book grades. They do make it hard to miss how different Yaupon's starting point was.

Our broader 2025 yearling data had him at a $110,000 median. That is not the same population as Keeneland September, so I would not call the move from $110,000 to $225,000 a year-over-year gain. It does show how quickly his commercial position has changed.

His fee is now $60,000. Breeders who used him at $25,000 in 2024 got in before most of that happened, and some pinhookers caught it as well. Twenty-two completed Yaupon pinhooks returned a 2.03x median gross multiple, with only 13.6 percent selling below public purchase price and $3.28 million in aggregate gross appreciation.

That is a large enough resale sample to get my attention.


Farther down the fee table

The same exercise gets more interesting for breeders who were operating in the $15,000 to $35,000 range.

Stallions standing between $15,000 and $35,000 for the 2024 breeding season
Sire2024 fee2026 feeKEESEP soldClearanceKEESEP medianCompleted pinhooksPinhook median multiple
Yaupon$25K$60K5787.7%$225K222.03x
Vekoma$15K$100K4080.0%$145K91.18x
Girvin$30K$30K4983.1%$140K81.51x
Army Mule$25K$25K4484.6%$110K82.06x
Maxfield$35K$50K3278.0%$150K62.95x
Golden Pal$25K$25K4193.2%$100K61.33x

Keeneland September figures are reported sales, including identifiable post-sale transactions. Pinhook multiples compare public purchase price to September resale price before expenses. Girvin stood the 2026 season at $30,000 and died on August 8, 2026.

The fee is only context. It is not ROI. The mare may represent far more capital than the season, and none of these numbers include discounts, foal shares, carrying costs or sales expenses.

Ranked bar chart. Keeneland September 2026 median divided by the 2024 stud fee. Vekoma 9.7x from a $15,000 fee, Yaupon 9.0x from $25,000, Nyquist 4.7x from $85,000, Girvin 4.7x, Army Mule 4.4x, Maxfield 4.3x, Not This Time 4.0x, Golden Pal 4.0x, Life Is Good 3.5x, Flightline 3.1x, Into Mischief 2.5x, Gun Runner 2.1x from a $250,000 fee, Uncle Mo 2.0x, Good Magic 1.8x, Justify 1.6x from a $200,000 fee.
Keeneland September 2026 median for each sire divided by his advertised 2024 stud fee, the season that produced these yearlings. Reported sales, including identifiable post-sale transactions.

Army Mule is probably the horse in this group I had underestimated most. He stood for $25,000 in 2024, and our broader 2025 yearling data put his median at $45,000. This September, 44 sold at a $110,000 median with 84.6 percent clearance. His fee is still $25,000.

He bred 160 mares in 2024, and mares sold in foal to him averaged just under $30,000. Eight completed pinhooks returned a 2.06x median gross multiple, with one selling below purchase price and $913,000 in gross appreciation across the group.

Eight horses are still eight horses, so I would not build too much around the pinhook number. The larger September population is what made me go back and look at him.

Girvin had 49 yearlings sell at a $140,000 median with 83.1 percent clearance. He stood for $30,000 when these horses were conceived, and his broader 2025 yearlings had a $51,000 median. Mares sold in foal to him in 2024 averaged about the same $51,000.

The eight completed pinhooks were mixed. Their median multiple was 1.51x and the median gross gain $72,500, but three sold below acquisition cost.

His story now has an unfortunate finite quality after his death in August at 12. These yearlings and the younger crops behind them are the remaining supply.

Vekoma is a different case again. He covered 202 mares in 2024 at a $15,000 fee, and mares sold in foal to him averaged about $45,000. Forty of those 2026 yearlings sold at Keeneland September for a $145,000 median.

His advertised fee today is $100,000.

That is a tremendous change in two and a half years, and it gets to what I think is the most interesting part of this whole exercise.


A few smaller signals

There were several smaller groups I would keep in the file without drawing much from them yet.

Maxfield had 32 September sales at a $150,000 median from a $35,000 2024 fee. Six completed pinhooks returned a 2.95x median multiple and about $1.5 million in gross appreciation. Six is not enough for much more than a note to look again next year.

Golden Pal had a different kind of sale. Forty-one of 44 offered yearlings found reported buyers, a 93.2 percent clearance rate, at a $100,000 median. His fee remains $25,000. I put much more weight on that September population than the six completed pinhooks in our sample.

Early Voting is interesting because the breeding market had already cooled. His fee fell from $20,000 in 2024 to $8,000 in 2025 before moving back to $12,500, yet 17 September yearlings sold at a $125,000 median with 89.5 percent clearance.

Five completed pinhooks produced a 4.00x median gross multiple and almost $1.2 million in gross appreciation. One horse bought for $300,000 and sold for $1.25 million did much of the dollar work, although $32,000 also became $130,000, $30,000 became $120,000 and $55,000 became $135,000. The fifth horse went from $70,000 to $50,000.

Corniche belongs in the same "interesting, too early" file. His fee has fallen from $25,000 in 2024 to $15,000, yet 13 September sales produced a $150,000 median. Seven matched pinhooks returned a 2.67x median and none sold below acquisition cost.

Pappacap is useful for a different reason. Nine completed pinhooks returned a 1.76x median multiple, but the median gross gain was only $14,500. After ten months of board, veterinary work, insurance, prep and commissions, a pretty multiple on a cheap horse can still be a very ordinary trade.

Those smaller samples are worth keeping in the file, but the larger groups tell us something more useful. Once I put the stud-fee history, mare-market context and pinhook results beside one another, the timing of the investment became hard to ignore.


Who actually captured the move?

The breeder and pinhooker experience the same sire at very different times.

The breeder made the mating in early 2024. The fee, the mare and whatever was known about the stallion at that moment were locked in long before this year's September sale.

The pinhooker arrived later. By then there were more runners, another yearling crop had sold and the market had had another chance to form an opinion. The buyer knew more, but so did the person selling the horse.

Vekoma is a good example. The breeder who used him at $15,000 entered before his runners changed his commercial position. By the time those foals were yearlings, the stallion was standing for $100,000 and the September median was $145,000.

Nine completed Vekoma pinhooks in our data returned a 1.18x median multiple, with three selling below purchase price. That does not tell me pinhookers were wrong about Vekoma. It tells me some of the Vekoma move had already made its way into the price of the horse by the time they bought.

Yaupon played out differently. His breeders also entered cheaply, at $25,000, but the re-rating was still underway when many of the weanlings and short yearlings traded. Twenty-two completed pinhooks later produced a 2.03x median multiple.

Army Mule may be another one to watch. His September yearling market moved considerably while his fee barely moved, and the small pinhook sample was good.

That is why "hot sire" is not a particularly useful investment conclusion by itself. The important question is when the market figured it out.

By the time a sire is obvious, somebody may already have been paid for discovering him.


What September said about the sire market

Gun Runner won the headlines coming out of Book 1. Not This Time got close enough over the full sale that the comparison between them is becoming hard to avoid.

Gun Runner produced the higher gross and more million-dollar horses. Not This Time produced the higher median from a 2024 fee that was $100,000 lower. Not This Time led the sire table by gross last year; Gun Runner took it back this year. I do not read that as one replacing the other. They are getting paid for somewhat different things, and there is plenty of room for both at the top of this market.

Yaupon got into the top 10 without a Book 1 sale, a million-dollar horse or anything close to a top-10 fee when these yearlings were conceived.

The 49 percent concentration fits what we have been watching at the front of September for years. What changed this time was how much farther it went. The top 10 sire groups added roughly $42 million in gross while the entire sale added about $27 million.

The mare-market data add another layer, although I would not make too much of a single proxy. September was judging crops conceived under 2024 fees and 2024 reputations, with the mares those stallions could attract at that point in their careers. The current version of Vekoma bears very little commercial resemblance to the $15,000 stallion who produced this crop. Yaupon has moved dramatically too.

That lag is part of what makes the sire market so interesting to follow. By the time Keeneland September gives us a clear answer about one crop, breeders and buyers are already several decisions farther down the road.

And then we do it all again.

Methodology. Thoroughbred Intelligence analyzed the complete Keeneland September 2026 catalog at the hip level using reported results through the close of the sale. Sire statistics include identifiable post-sale transactions. Clearance is reported sales divided by horses offered, with withdrawals excluded. Keeneland reported $536.7 million in through-ring sales for 2,856 yearlings and $558.3 million including reported post-sales.

Books are consecutive session pairs, with Book 1 covering sessions 1 and 2 and the sixth pair covering sessions 11 and 12. Keeneland labelled that final pair Book 6 through 2024 and renamed it Book 5B in 2025, so this analysis uses consecutive session pairs throughout to keep the years comparable.

Historical concentration figures use final Keeneland September sale totals and sire-level reported results on a comparable basis for 2024 through 2026. Post-sale reporting can continue after a sale closes, so small subsequent changes are possible.

Advertised stud fees, prior yearling-sale medians, mare books and covering-sire averages come from Thoroughbred Intelligence's stallion research. The 2024 fee and mares bred correspond to the breeding season that produced the 2026 yearlings. Prior-year yearling medians describe broader sale populations and are not presented as direct Keeneland September year-over-year comparisons.

The covering-sire average is the average public sale price of mares sold in foal to the stallion during the stated year. It represents only mares that came to public auction, and the value of the pregnancy is embedded in the mare's sale price. I use it as an imperfect measure of the commercial profile surrounding a stallion's book, not as an estimate of average mare quality or the value of the entire book.

Pinhook figures use the matched purchase-to-September transaction population developed for our full-sale pinhook analysis. Gross multiples and gross appreciation compare public purchase and resale prices before commissions, board, insurance, veterinary work, transportation, sales preparation, financing and other carrying costs. Small sire-level samples are identified as such.