The First-Year Bet and the Changing Economics of Breeding Thoroughbreds in Kentucky

How Kentucky’s stallion market has changed and what that means for a breeder booking a first-season stallion in 2027.

In this article
  1. Kentucky Has Kept the Mares and Lost the Stallions
  2. Book Quality Has Fallen in Every Fee Tier Below $100,000
  3. First-Season Stallions Now Cover One-Fifth of Kentucky’s Mares
  4. What Became of 148 Commercial Newcomers?
  5. The Market’s Second Opinion Is Often Brutal
  6. Even the Best First Books Offer Little Protection
  7. What the Breeder Actually Has to Make Back
  8. November Has Started Sorting the Next Generations
  9. Seven Newcomers, a Bigger Price Tag and the Same Mares
  10. A Game of Musical Chairs
  11. So What Should a Breeder Do?

My Thoroughbred Daily News column on Kentucky’s 2027 stallion market ran on November 16, 2026: A Game of Musical Chairs: Kentucky’s 2027 Stallion Market.

Breeding figures through The Jockey Club’s reports received by November 13, 2026. 2027 status from TI’s Kentucky stud fee roster as of November 10, 2026.

Racing has a few weeks left this year, but the major yearling and breeding stock sales are behind us, the stallions that matter have been priced for 2027, and the races that move those prices have been run. I’ve been crunching data and talking with people from every corner of the business since August. That has meant breeders and pinhookers of every size, from mom-and-pop farms to large-scale breeders; respected trainers and bloodstock agents; and sales company executives and people involved in running Kentucky’s largest stallion farms. Between the data, being on the ground at the sales and those conversations, a few threads kept surfacing, and I felt compelled to follow them. This is the first.

It came up in nearly every conversation: what a breeder does when the stallions everyone wants cost six figures, and how much it now costs to breed a foal that has a chance to return a profit. For years, part of the answer was a first-season stallion. A breeder priced out of Not This Time, Nyquist or Into Mischief could book a newcomer with a racing record and a large opening book. The bet is on timing: the first foals reach the sales before the first runners reach the races, so the breeder sells on promise.

That way in is getting expensive too. Of the twenty first-season stallions entering Kentucky next spring, seven will open at advertised fees of $50,000 or more, led by Sovereignty at $150,000, Nysos at $80,000 and Knightsbridge at $75,000. Sovereignty’s fee is twice the $75,000 Sierra Leone commanded as last year’s most expensive newcomer. Across the preceding seven years combined, only twelve first-season stallions opened at $50,000 or more, and no class had more than three.

Those seven are charging $50,000 or more before any of their foals has been born. So we asked how often a newcomer has gone on to earn that kind of fee. We followed 148 stallions that entered stud from 2015 through 2021 and had at least fifteen first-crop horses cataloged at Kentucky’s principal commercial auctions. The 2015 class is the earliest our sales records can follow from the start, and the 2021 class is the latest whose runners have raced for three seasons before the 2027 fees were set. Thirteen of the 148, or 8.8%, stand for $50,000 or more in Kentucky in 2027.

Before following those stallions through the sales ring, we look at how the Kentucky market itself has changed: fewer stallions, bigger books, and lower-rated mares going to every fee range below $100,000. Then we follow the 148 crop by crop, measure what it costs to breed a yearling that can return a profit, and see how this year’s young stallions are already being sorted. We finish with the seven 2027 newcomers, two forecasts we will score, and what I would do as a breeder.

Kentucky Has Kept the Mares and Lost the Stallions

Kentucky’s mare population is close to where it stood sixteen years ago. In 2010, 299 active stallions covered 17,460 mares. This year, 189 stallions covered 16,696. There are more than a hundred fewer horses standing in the state, and almost as many mares to go around.

Seventeen stallions covered at least 150 mares in 2010, accounting for 16.3% of the state’s coverings. In 2026, forty-three stallions reached that mark and covered 51.7%. The average book rose from 58 mares to 88, while the top twenty stallions increased their share from 18.8% to 27.2%.

Kentucky breeding measure201020162026
Active stallions299249189
Mares bred17,46017,92416,696
Average book587288
Stallions covering 150+ mares172943
Share of mares in those books16.3%28.1%51.7%

The mare-weighted median advertised fee in Kentucky was $15,000 from 2012 through 2017 and has been $25,000 since 2023. In 2012, 64.8% of the state’s mares went to stallions advertised below $25,000. This year it was 39.1%.

Figure 1 · The fee ladder

Kentucky mares bred to stallions under $25,000 fell from 64.8% to 39.1%

Share of Kentucky mares bred, by the stallion’s advertised fee, 2012 to 2026 2012: under $25,000 64.8%, $25,000 or more 31.5%; 2013: under $25,000 64.6%, $25,000 or more 33.1%; 2014: under $25,000 67.3%, $25,000 or more 30.8%; 2015: under $25,000 61.9%, $25,000 or more 34.9%; 2016: under $25,000 62.5%, $25,000 or more 36.3%; 2017: under $25,000 58.2%, $25,000 or more 40.0%; 2018: under $25,000 56.0%, $25,000 or more 42.4%; 2019: under $25,000 53.3%, $25,000 or more 45.0%; 2020: under $25,000 51.7%, $25,000 or more 45.5%; 2021: under $25,000 58.0%, $25,000 or more 39.7%; 2022: under $25,000 56.8%, $25,000 or more 41.8%; 2023: under $25,000 47.8%, $25,000 or more 49.9%; 2024: under $25,000 42.6%, $25,000 or more 55.3%; 2025: under $25,000 44.3%, $25,000 or more 54.7%; 2026: under $25,000 39.1%, $25,000 or more 60.3% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 2026 Under $25,000 $25,000 or more 2012: under $25,000 64.8% of Kentucky mares 2013: under $25,000 64.6% of Kentucky mares 2014: under $25,000 67.3% of Kentucky mares 2015: under $25,000 61.9% of Kentucky mares 2016: under $25,000 62.5% of Kentucky mares 2017: under $25,000 58.2% of Kentucky mares 2018: under $25,000 56.0% of Kentucky mares 2019: under $25,000 53.3% of Kentucky mares 2020: under $25,000 51.7% of Kentucky mares 2021: under $25,000 58.0% of Kentucky mares 2022: under $25,000 56.8% of Kentucky mares 2023: under $25,000 47.8% of Kentucky mares 2024: under $25,000 42.6% of Kentucky mares 2025: under $25,000 44.3% of Kentucky mares 2026: under $25,000 39.1% of Kentucky mares 2012: $25,000 or more 31.5% of Kentucky mares 2013: $25,000 or more 33.1% of Kentucky mares 2014: $25,000 or more 30.8% of Kentucky mares 2015: $25,000 or more 34.9% of Kentucky mares 2016: $25,000 or more 36.3% of Kentucky mares 2017: $25,000 or more 40.0% of Kentucky mares 2018: $25,000 or more 42.4% of Kentucky mares 2019: $25,000 or more 45.0% of Kentucky mares 2020: $25,000 or more 45.5% of Kentucky mares 2021: $25,000 or more 39.7% of Kentucky mares 2022: $25,000 or more 41.8% of Kentucky mares 2023: $25,000 or more 49.9% of Kentucky mares 2024: $25,000 or more 55.3% of Kentucky mares 2025: $25,000 or more 54.7% of Kentucky mares 2026: $25,000 or more 60.3% of Kentucky mares 60.3% 39.1% 64.8% 31.5% $25,000 or more under $25,000 Share of Kentucky mares bred, by the stallion’s advertised fee, 2012 to 2026 2012: under $25,000 64.8%, $25,000 or more 31.5%; 2013: under $25,000 64.6%, $25,000 or more 33.1%; 2014: under $25,000 67.3%, $25,000 or more 30.8%; 2015: under $25,000 61.9%, $25,000 or more 34.9%; 2016: under $25,000 62.5%, $25,000 or more 36.3%; 2017: under $25,000 58.2%, $25,000 or more 40.0%; 2018: under $25,000 56.0%, $25,000 or more 42.4%; 2019: under $25,000 53.3%, $25,000 or more 45.0%; 2020: under $25,000 51.7%, $25,000 or more 45.5%; 2021: under $25,000 58.0%, $25,000 or more 39.7%; 2022: under $25,000 56.8%, $25,000 or more 41.8%; 2023: under $25,000 47.8%, $25,000 or more 49.9%; 2024: under $25,000 42.6%, $25,000 or more 55.3%; 2025: under $25,000 44.3%, $25,000 or more 54.7%; 2026: under $25,000 39.1%, $25,000 or more 60.3% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 2026 Under $25,000 $25,000 or more 2012: under $25,000 64.8% of Kentucky mares 2013: under $25,000 64.6% of Kentucky mares 2014: under $25,000 67.3% of Kentucky mares 2015: under $25,000 61.9% of Kentucky mares 2016: under $25,000 62.5% of Kentucky mares 2017: under $25,000 58.2% of Kentucky mares 2018: under $25,000 56.0% of Kentucky mares 2019: under $25,000 53.3% of Kentucky mares 2020: under $25,000 51.7% of Kentucky mares 2021: under $25,000 58.0% of Kentucky mares 2022: under $25,000 56.8% of Kentucky mares 2023: under $25,000 47.8% of Kentucky mares 2024: under $25,000 42.6% of Kentucky mares 2025: under $25,000 44.3% of Kentucky mares 2026: under $25,000 39.1% of Kentucky mares 2012: $25,000 or more 31.5% of Kentucky mares 2013: $25,000 or more 33.1% of Kentucky mares 2014: $25,000 or more 30.8% of Kentucky mares 2015: $25,000 or more 34.9% of Kentucky mares 2016: $25,000 or more 36.3% of Kentucky mares 2017: $25,000 or more 40.0% of Kentucky mares 2018: $25,000 or more 42.4% of Kentucky mares 2019: $25,000 or more 45.0% of Kentucky mares 2020: $25,000 or more 45.5% of Kentucky mares 2021: $25,000 or more 39.7% of Kentucky mares 2022: $25,000 or more 41.8% of Kentucky mares 2023: $25,000 or more 49.9% of Kentucky mares 2024: $25,000 or more 55.3% of Kentucky mares 2025: $25,000 or more 54.7% of Kentucky mares 2026: $25,000 or more 60.3% of Kentucky mares 60.3% 39.1% 64.8% 31.5%
Kentucky mares bred by the stallion’s advertised fee for that season, as a share of all Kentucky mares bred, 2012 to 2026. Mares bred to stallions with no published fee, between 0.6% and 3.7% a year, are counted in the total but in neither line.

Twelve Kentucky stallions advertised at $100,000 or more covered about 12% of the state’s mares in 2026 and 47.7% of the list-price value of matings with known fees, counted as advertised fee times mares bred. Kentucky’s share of North American mares bred grew from about 39% in 2010 to 63% in 2025, as the reported total fell from 44,906 to 26,035. More of the business is here, and a breeder with a commercial mare faces fewer Kentucky stallions and a larger premium for the established names.

Book Quality Has Fallen in Every Fee Tier Below $100,000

Counting mares tells us little about their quality, and quality is what a breeder is weighing between a $25,000 season, a $50,000 one and the top of the market. BloodHorse’s annual Quality of Mares Bred reports grade each stallion’s book with the Comparable Index, or CI, which measures how much the mares’ foals by other stallions have earned against the average runner. A CI of 1.00 is average; a CI of 2.00 means those foals have earned twice as much. We collected it for every Kentucky stallion covering at least twenty mares from 2020 through 2025 and weighted each book by its mares.

Kentucky’s overall book CI moved from 1.82 in 2020 to 1.75 in 2025. Every advertised fee tier below $100,000 had a lower mare-weighted CI in 2025 than in 2020. The $100,000-plus tier moved up from 3.75 to 3.93, with considerable fluctuation in between.

Stallion’s advertised fee2020 mares2020 book CI2025 mares2025 book CI
Under $10,0002,6251.171,9881.09
$10,000 to $24,9995,6101.374,9021.21
$25,000 to $49,9994,7851.875,4041.65
$50,000 to $99,9991,2412.261,8272.09
$100,000+1,4403.751,7533.93

Figure 2 · The squeeze in the middle

Book quality fell in every Kentucky fee tier below $100,000

Mare-weighted Comparable Index of Kentucky books, by advertised fee tier, 2020 to 2025, indexed to 2020 Under $10,000: 1.17 in 2020, 1.09 in 2025; $10,000 to $24,999: 1.37 in 2020, 1.21 in 2025; $25,000 to $49,999: 1.87 in 2020, 1.65 in 2025; $50,000 to $99,999: 2.26 in 2020, 2.09 in 2025; $100,000+: 3.75 in 2020, 3.93 in 2025 Under $10,000 1.17 → 1.09 −7% Under $10,000, 2020: book CI 1.17 on 2,625 mares Under $10,000, 2021: book CI 1.13 on 3,541 mares Under $10,000, 2022: book CI 1.06 on 3,179 mares Under $10,000, 2023: book CI 1.06 on 2,585 mares Under $10,000, 2024: book CI 1.08 on 1,944 mares Under $10,000, 2025: book CI 1.09 on 1,988 mares 2020 2025 $10,000 to $24,999 1.37 → 1.21 −12% $10,000 to $24,999, 2020: book CI 1.37 on 5,610 mares $10,000 to $24,999, 2021: book CI 1.37 on 5,652 mares $10,000 to $24,999, 2022: book CI 1.31 on 6,112 mares $10,000 to $24,999, 2023: book CI 1.25 on 5,270 mares $10,000 to $24,999, 2024: book CI 1.19 on 4,844 mares $10,000 to $24,999, 2025: book CI 1.21 on 4,902 mares 2020 2025 $25,000 to $49,999 1.87 → 1.65 −12% $25,000 to $49,999, 2020: book CI 1.87 on 4,785 mares $25,000 to $49,999, 2021: book CI 1.91 on 3,713 mares $25,000 to $49,999, 2022: book CI 1.69 on 3,176 mares $25,000 to $49,999, 2023: book CI 1.62 on 4,518 mares $25,000 to $49,999, 2024: book CI 1.54 on 4,879 mares $25,000 to $49,999, 2025: book CI 1.65 on 5,404 mares 2020 2025 $50,000 to $99,999 2.26 → 2.09 −8% $50,000 to $99,999, 2020: book CI 2.26 on 1,241 mares $50,000 to $99,999, 2021: book CI 2.57 on 1,440 mares $50,000 to $99,999, 2022: book CI 2.30 on 2,597 mares $50,000 to $99,999, 2023: book CI 2.03 on 2,068 mares $50,000 to $99,999, 2024: book CI 2.06 on 2,466 mares $50,000 to $99,999, 2025: book CI 2.09 on 1,827 mares 2020 2025 $100,000+ 3.75 → 3.93 +5% $100,000+, 2020: book CI 3.75 on 1,440 mares $100,000+, 2021: book CI 4.02 on 1,210 mares $100,000+, 2022: book CI 3.87 on 1,223 mares $100,000+, 2023: book CI 3.35 on 1,892 mares $100,000+, 2024: book CI 4.12 on 1,831 mares $100,000+, 2025: book CI 3.93 on 1,753 mares 2020 2025 Each panel: book CI as a share of its own 2020 level; the dashed line is the 2020 level. Mare-weighted Comparable Index of Kentucky books, by advertised fee tier, 2020 to 2025, indexed to 2020 Under $10,000: 1.17 in 2020, 1.09 in 2025; $10,000 to $24,999: 1.37 in 2020, 1.21 in 2025; $25,000 to $49,999: 1.87 in 2020, 1.65 in 2025; $50,000 to $99,999: 2.26 in 2020, 2.09 in 2025; $100,000+: 3.75 in 2020, 3.93 in 2025 Under $10,000 1.17 → 1.09 −7% since 2020 Under $10,000, 2020: book CI 1.17 Under $10,000, 2021: book CI 1.13 Under $10,000, 2022: book CI 1.06 Under $10,000, 2023: book CI 1.06 Under $10,000, 2024: book CI 1.08 Under $10,000, 2025: book CI 1.09 $10,000 to $24,999 1.37 → 1.21 −12% since 2020 $10,000 to $24,999, 2020: book CI 1.37 $10,000 to $24,999, 2021: book CI 1.37 $10,000 to $24,999, 2022: book CI 1.31 $10,000 to $24,999, 2023: book CI 1.25 $10,000 to $24,999, 2024: book CI 1.19 $10,000 to $24,999, 2025: book CI 1.21 $25,000 to $49,999 1.87 → 1.65 −12% since 2020 $25,000 to $49,999, 2020: book CI 1.87 $25,000 to $49,999, 2021: book CI 1.91 $25,000 to $49,999, 2022: book CI 1.69 $25,000 to $49,999, 2023: book CI 1.62 $25,000 to $49,999, 2024: book CI 1.54 $25,000 to $49,999, 2025: book CI 1.65 $50,000 to $99,999 2.26 → 2.09 −8% since 2020 $50,000 to $99,999, 2020: book CI 2.26 $50,000 to $99,999, 2021: book CI 2.57 $50,000 to $99,999, 2022: book CI 2.30 $50,000 to $99,999, 2023: book CI 2.03 $50,000 to $99,999, 2024: book CI 2.06 $50,000 to $99,999, 2025: book CI 2.09 $100,000+ 3.75 → 3.93 +5% since 2020 $100,000+, 2020: book CI 3.75 $100,000+, 2021: book CI 4.02 $100,000+, 2022: book CI 3.87 $100,000+, 2023: book CI 3.35 $100,000+, 2024: book CI 4.12 $100,000+, 2025: book CI 3.93
Mare-weighted book CI for Kentucky stallions covering 20 or more mares, by the stallion’s advertised fee, 2020 to 2025. Each panel is scaled to its own 2020 level so the tiers can be compared; the actual indexes are in the data table. Tiers gain and lose stallions as fees change.

Look at the $50,000-to-$99,999 tier. Its book CI reached 2.57 in 2021 and fell to 2.09 in 2025 while it took on more mares; stallions at $50,000 or more covered 2,681 Kentucky mares in 2020 and 3,580 in 2025. I suspect many breeders have been moving a mare a rung or two up the fee ladder, so each tier fills with mares that would once have gone to a cheaper stallion. The reports do not follow individual mares, so that is my reading of the pattern.

The same stallion at the same price tells the same story. BloodHorse prints each established stallion’s change in book quality from one season to the next. Among Kentucky stallions whose fees did not change, between 55.8% and 61.6% drew weaker books in each season from 2021 through 2025, and their mare-weighted CI fell 10.3% over those five comparisons. Stallions whose fees rose drew better books, and those whose fees fell drew weaker ones.

At Keeneland November, mares in foal to $50,000-to-$99,999 stallions sold for a $152,500 median, 2.50 times the covering fee, from 2016 through 2018. From 2023 through 2026 the median was $125,000 and the multiple 2.10, as the number sold rose from 316 to 594. The mares differ across those periods, and the direction is consistent with a middle market under pressure.

That matters for the bet. A stallion’s runners come from his mares, and at every price below $100,000 the mares have been getting weaker.

First-Season Stallions Now Cover One-Fifth of Kentucky’s Mares

First-season stallions covered 1,526 Kentucky mares in 2010, or 8.7% of the state total. By 2016 they covered 3,473, or 19.4%. Their share peaked at 24.3% in 2023. This year’s 27 newcomers covered 3,218 mares, 19.3% of the total, with sixteen booking at least a hundred.

Among newcomers with at least fifty mares, the median opening book rose from 112 in 2010 to 135.5 in 2016 and 183 this year, counting only the newcomers who reached fifty.

At Keeneland November this month, mares in foal to stallions standing their first season in 2026 sold for a $62,000 median, 2.13 times the covering sire’s advertised fee, against $45,000 and 1.60 times fee for other pregnant mares. Sierra Leone alone had nineteen covered mares sell for $6.74 million. The two groups carried different mares, so part of the gap belongs to the mares.

Stallions that entered stud in 2025 supplied 585 of the 1,603 weanlings cataloged at Keeneland November 2026. Their 317 sold foals brought $28.6 million at a $70,000 median. The prior class had sold its first-crop weanlings at an $80,000 median. Ring clearance fell from 79.1% for that earlier group to 72.2% this year.

Twenty-one of the twenty-two first-crop stallions with published 2027 fees now stand for less than their 2025 debut fee; Arabian Knight is still at $30,000. Seventeen were cut for 2027, as our November review reported, and four had already been cut for 2026. Their first yearlings have yet to sell, and the farms are already repricing them. The market pays a premium for promise at every stage until the first foals sell.

What Became of 148 Commercial Newcomers?

Our historical group includes only commercially represented stallions, each with at least fifteen first-crop entries across Keeneland September and November and Fasig-Tipton October and November. Smaller operations and horses bred mainly outside the auction market are not in the sample.

Figure 3 · Who is still standing

Of 148 commercial newcomers from 2015 to 2021, 38 still stand in Kentucky and 13 stand for $50,000 or more

Where the 148 commercial newcomers of 2015 to 2021 stand in 2027, one square per stallion 2015: 18 stallions, 0 at $50,000 or more, 3 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2016: 27 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 2 in Kentucky below $50,000, 23 no longer on the roster; 2017: 25 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 1 in Kentucky below $50,000, 22 no longer on the roster; 2018: 17 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 0 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2019: 23 stallions, 3 at $50,000 or more, 5 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2020: 14 stallions, 1 at $50,000 or more, 5 in Kentucky below $50,000, 8 no longer on the roster; 2021: 24 stallions, 3 at $50,000 or more, 9 in Kentucky below $50,000, 12 no longer on the roster $50,000 or more in 2027 $50,000 or more in 2027 In Kentucky below $50,000 In Kentucky below $50,000 No longer in Kentucky No longer in Kentucky 2015 Cairo Prince (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Goldencents (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Real Solution (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Atreides (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Can the Man (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cross Traffic (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Fed Biz (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Flashback (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Itsmyluckyday (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Magician (IRE) (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mark Valeski (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mucho Macho Man (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Noble Mission (GB) (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Revolutionary (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Shakin It Up (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Strong Mandate (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Verrazano (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Will Take Charge (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster 3 of 18 2016 Constitution (entered 2016): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Liam's Map (entered 2016): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Karakontie (JPN) (entered 2016): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Tonalist (entered 2016): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 American Pharoah (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Bayern (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Carpe Diem (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Commissioner (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Competitive Edge (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Conveyance (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Danza (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Daredevil (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Fast Anna (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Hampton Court (AUS) (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Honor Code (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Jack Milton (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Lea (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Medal Count (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mr Speaker (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Palace (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Palace Malice (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Race Day (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Secret Circle (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Sky Kingdom (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Summer Front (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tapiture (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Wicked Strong (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster 4 of 27 2017 Not This Time (entered 2017): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Nyquist (entered 2017): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Upstart (entered 2017): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Air Force Blue (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Anchor Down (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Big Blue Kitten (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Brody's Cause (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster California Chrome (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cinco Charlie (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Exaggerator (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Firing Line (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Flintshire (GB) (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Frosted (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Hit It a Bomb (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Ironicus (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Laoban (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mshawish (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Optimizer (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Outwork (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Runhappy (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Speightster (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tamarkuz (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Texas Red (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tourist (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Vancouver (AUS) (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster 3 of 25 2018 Gun Runner (entered 2018): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Practical Joke (entered 2018): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 American Freedom (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Arrogate (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Astern (AUS) (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Bal a Bali (BRZ) (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Classic Empire (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Connect (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cupid (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Gormley (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Keen Ice (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Klimt (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Lord Nelson (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mastery (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Midnight Storm (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mohaymen (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Unified (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster 2 of 17 2019 Good Magic (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Justify (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Oscar Performance (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Army Mule (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Bee Jersey (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Bolt d'Oro (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 City of Light (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Funtastic (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Accelerate (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Always Dreaming (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cloud Computing (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Collected (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Free Drop Billy (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Girvin (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Good Samaritan (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster McCraken (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mendelssohn (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mo Town (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mor Spirit (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Ransom the Moon (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Sharp Azteca (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tapwrit (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster West Coast (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster 8 of 23 2020 Omaha Beach (entered 2020): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Audible (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Flameaway (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Maximus Mischief (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Mitole (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Vino Rosso (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Catalina Cruiser (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Catholic Boy (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Copper Bullet (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Demarchelier (GB) (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Enticed (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Preservationist (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster World of Trouble (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Yoshida (JPN) (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster 6 of 14 2021 McKinzie (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Tiz the Law (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Vekoma (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Authentic (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Caracaro (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Complexity (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Country House (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Honor A. P. (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Instagrand (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Instilled Regard (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Promises Fulfilled (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Volatile (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Echo Town (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Game Winner (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Gift Box (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Global Campaign (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Higher Power (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Improbable (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Maximum Security (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Shancelot (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Spun to Run (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Thousand Words (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tom's d'Etat (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster War of Will (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster 12 of 24 Where the 148 commercial newcomers of 2015 to 2021 stand in 2027, one square per stallion 2015: 18 stallions, 0 at $50,000 or more, 3 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2016: 27 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 2 in Kentucky below $50,000, 23 no longer on the roster; 2017: 25 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 1 in Kentucky below $50,000, 22 no longer on the roster; 2018: 17 stallions, 2 at $50,000 or more, 0 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2019: 23 stallions, 3 at $50,000 or more, 5 in Kentucky below $50,000, 15 no longer on the roster; 2020: 14 stallions, 1 at $50,000 or more, 5 in Kentucky below $50,000, 8 no longer on the roster; 2021: 24 stallions, 3 at $50,000 or more, 9 in Kentucky below $50,000, 12 no longer on the roster $50,000 or more in 2027 $50,000 or more in 2027 In Kentucky below $50,000 In Kentucky below $50,000 No longer in Kentucky No longer in Kentucky 2015 Cairo Prince (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Goldencents (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Real Solution (entered 2015): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Atreides (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Can the Man (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cross Traffic (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Fed Biz (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Flashback (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Itsmyluckyday (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Magician (IRE) (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mark Valeski (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mucho Macho Man (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Noble Mission (GB) (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Revolutionary (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Shakin It Up (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Strong Mandate (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Verrazano (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster Will Take Charge (entered 2015): no longer on the Kentucky roster 3 of 18 2016 Constitution (entered 2016): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Liam's Map (entered 2016): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Karakontie (JPN) (entered 2016): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Tonalist (entered 2016): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 American Pharoah (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Bayern (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Carpe Diem (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Commissioner (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Competitive Edge (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Conveyance (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Danza (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Daredevil (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Fast Anna (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Hampton Court (AUS) (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Honor Code (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Jack Milton (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Lea (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Medal Count (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mr Speaker (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Palace (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Palace Malice (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Race Day (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Secret Circle (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Sky Kingdom (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Summer Front (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tapiture (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster Wicked Strong (entered 2016): no longer on the Kentucky roster 4 of 27 2017 Not This Time (entered 2017): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Nyquist (entered 2017): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Upstart (entered 2017): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Air Force Blue (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Anchor Down (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Big Blue Kitten (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Brody's Cause (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster California Chrome (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cinco Charlie (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Exaggerator (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Firing Line (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Flintshire (GB) (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Frosted (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Hit It a Bomb (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Ironicus (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Laoban (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mshawish (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Optimizer (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Outwork (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Runhappy (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Speightster (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tamarkuz (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Texas Red (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tourist (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster Vancouver (AUS) (entered 2017): no longer on the Kentucky roster 3 of 25 2018 Gun Runner (entered 2018): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Practical Joke (entered 2018): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 American Freedom (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Arrogate (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Astern (AUS) (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Bal a Bali (BRZ) (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Classic Empire (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Connect (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cupid (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Gormley (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Keen Ice (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Klimt (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Lord Nelson (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mastery (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Midnight Storm (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mohaymen (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster Unified (entered 2018): no longer on the Kentucky roster 2 of 17 2019 Good Magic (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Justify (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Oscar Performance (entered 2019): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Army Mule (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Bee Jersey (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Bolt d'Oro (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 City of Light (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Funtastic (entered 2019): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Accelerate (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Always Dreaming (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Cloud Computing (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Collected (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Free Drop Billy (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Girvin (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Good Samaritan (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster McCraken (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mendelssohn (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mo Town (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Mor Spirit (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Ransom the Moon (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Sharp Azteca (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tapwrit (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster West Coast (entered 2019): no longer on the Kentucky roster 8 of 23 2020 Omaha Beach (entered 2020): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Audible (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Flameaway (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Maximus Mischief (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Mitole (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Vino Rosso (entered 2020): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Catalina Cruiser (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Catholic Boy (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Copper Bullet (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Demarchelier (GB) (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Enticed (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Preservationist (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster World of Trouble (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster Yoshida (JPN) (entered 2020): no longer on the Kentucky roster 6 of 14 2021 McKinzie (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Tiz the Law (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Vekoma (entered 2021): stands for $50,000 or more in 2027 Authentic (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Caracaro (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Complexity (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Country House (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Honor A. P. (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Instagrand (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Instilled Regard (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Promises Fulfilled (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Volatile (entered 2021): still stands in Kentucky below $50,000 Echo Town (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Game Winner (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Gift Box (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Global Campaign (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Higher Power (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Improbable (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Maximum Security (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Shancelot (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Spun to Run (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Thousand Words (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster Tom's d'Etat (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster War of Will (entered 2021): no longer on the Kentucky roster 12 of 24
Each square is one stallion that entered stud from 2015 through 2021 with at least fifteen first-crop horses cataloged at Keeneland September and November and Fasig-Tipton October and November, placed by his status on TI’s November 10, 2026 Kentucky fee roster. The number at the end of each row counts the stallions still standing in Kentucky. Outlined squares include the seven stallions that died while standing in Kentucky.

The thirteen at $50,000 or more in 2027 are Constitution, Liam’s Map, Not This Time, Nyquist, Gun Runner, Practical Joke, Justify, Good Magic, Oscar Performance, Omaha Beach, Vekoma, Tiz the Law and McKinzie.

Seven of the 110 no longer on the Kentucky roster died while standing here: Arrogate in 2020; Fast Anna, Laoban and Lord Nelson in 2021; Improbable in 2024; and Frosted and Girvin in 2026. Excluding those seven leaves thirteen of 141, or 9.2%, reaching the Kentucky fee threshold.

Of the 103 that left Kentucky alive, forty-one were exported, including eight to Japan and eight to South Korea, and American Pharoah is on a two-season lease to Japan. Forty-five moved elsewhere in North America, four were pensioned, four died after leaving, and eight dropped out of the Jockey Club’s reports with no public record of where they went. A horse can thrive after leaving Kentucky. What we measure is a place on Kentucky’s 2027 fee roster, and the 2015 entrants have had twelve seasons to earn one while the 2021 entrants have had six.

The Market’s Second Opinion Is Often Brutal

We compared each stallion’s median sold-weanling price at Keeneland and Fasig-Tipton November with the median for all sold weanlings at those sales in the same year. An index of 1.00 means the stallion matched the market; 2.00 means his median was twice the market. A stallion needed at least three sales to appear in a given crop year. We then looked at the stallions by their eventual 2027 Kentucky status.

Stallion’s 2027 Kentucky statusFirst cropSecond cropThird cropFourth crop
Fee $50,000+2.611.872.751.90
In Kentucky below $50,0001.190.730.600.55
No longer in Kentucky0.940.500.320.18

The stallions no longer standing in Kentucky began with first-crop weanlings priced near the prevailing market median, at an index of 0.94. Their second crop brought half the market, their third less than a third, and their fourth less than a fifth.

Figure 4 · Who stays and who goes

The stallions that left Kentucky sold their first crop near the market and their fourth at less than a fifth of it

Median sire weanling index by crop, 2015 to 2021 Kentucky entrants, grouped by 2027 status Fee $50,000+ in 2027: crop 1 2.61, crop 2 1.87, crop 3 2.75, crop 4 1.90; In Kentucky below $50,000: crop 1 1.19, crop 2 0.73, crop 3 0.60, crop 4 0.55; No longer in Kentucky: crop 1 0.94, crop 2 0.50, crop 3 0.32, crop 4 0.18 0 1.00 2.00 3.00 market median First crop Second Third Fourth Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 1: median index 2.61 (13 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 2: median index 1.87 (12 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 3: median index 2.75 (13 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 4: median index 1.90 (12 sires) 1.90 Fee $50,000+ in 2027 2.61 In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 1: median index 1.19 (21 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 2: median index 0.73 (18 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 3: median index 0.60 (15 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 4: median index 0.55 (16 sires) 0.55 In Kentucky below $50,000 1.19 No longer in Kentucky, crop 1: median index 0.94 (102 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 2: median index 0.50 (72 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 3: median index 0.32 (59 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 4: median index 0.18 (41 sires) 0.18 No longer in Kentucky 0.94 Median sire weanling index by crop, 2015 to 2021 Kentucky entrants, grouped by 2027 status Fee $50,000+ in 2027: crop 1 2.61, crop 2 1.87, crop 3 2.75, crop 4 1.90; In Kentucky below $50,000: crop 1 1.19, crop 2 0.73, crop 3 0.60, crop 4 0.55; No longer in Kentucky: crop 1 0.94, crop 2 0.50, crop 3 0.32, crop 4 0.18 0 1.00 2.00 3.00 market median First crop Second Third Fourth Fee $50,000+ in 2027 In Kentucky below $50,000 No longer in Kentucky Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 1: median index 2.61 (13 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 2: median index 1.87 (12 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 3: median index 2.75 (13 sires) Fee $50,000+ in 2027, crop 4: median index 1.90 (12 sires) 1.90 2.61 In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 1: median index 1.19 (21 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 2: median index 0.73 (18 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 3: median index 0.60 (15 sires) In Kentucky below $50,000, crop 4: median index 0.55 (16 sires) 0.55 1.19 No longer in Kentucky, crop 1: median index 0.94 (102 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 2: median index 0.50 (72 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 3: median index 0.32 (59 sires) No longer in Kentucky, crop 4: median index 0.18 (41 sires) 0.18 0.94
The 148 commercial entrants of 2015 to 2021, by where they stand on the 2027 Kentucky roster. 1.00 is the market median for sold weanlings in that crop’s sale year; post-sales included, RNAs and withdrawn horses left out.

A breeder who sold a first foal near the market median was paid before the decline. One who made the same mating a year or two later met a market that had already marked down the sire’s stock.

The thirteen that reached $50,000 began far ahead, at a median first-crop index of 2.61. They eased to 1.87 in the second crop and recovered to 2.75 in the third, once their runners had begun to race. The first crop already sorted much of the field. Among 136 sires with at least three first-crop weanlings sold, none of the 48 in the bottom third of their class reached $50,000 for 2027, one of the 43 in the middle third did, and twelve of the 45 in the top third did. Every one of the thirteen opened at an index of at least 1.43. These are hindsight groups, and some fading stallions sent too few foals to auction to qualify in later crops.

A strong first crop guaranteed nothing. Classic Empire’s first weanlings sold at 3.79 times the market median, and his next three crops at 1.33, 0.61 and 0.28. Runhappy opened at 3.86 and held 3.45 before falling to 0.67. Honor Code began at 3.75 and his fourth crop indexed at 0.30. None stands in Kentucky for 2027, and neither does American Pharoah, although his auction prices held up much better. Arrogate’s death puts him outside the comparison.

The mares explain part of that. BloodHorse rates a sire’s lifetime books with CI and his runners’ earnings with the Average Earnings Index, or AEI, both on a scale where 1.00 is average. American Pharoah’s books carry a lifetime CI of 2.07 and his runners an AEI of 1.38; Honor Code’s figures are 1.74 and 1.07, Runhappy’s 1.64 and 1.17. Each was sent good mares and got less from them than other stallions did. Vekoma’s books are rated 1.18, his runners have earned at 1.89, and he stands for $100,000 in 2027.

Sorting the newcomers by their fourth-season books gives the same picture. Those still covering at least a hundred mares had first-crop weanlings at an index of 2.00 and held 1.46 and 1.20 in the next two crops. Those that fell below fifty or vanished from the Jockey Club’s reports started at 0.73 and slipped to 0.24 and 0.17. Weak prices cost a stallion mares, and lost mares weaken his foals; the data cannot say which comes first.

Even the Best First Books Offer Little Protection

When a newcomer’s first foals sell, buyers have his race record, pedigree, fee and the quality of his first book to go on. For 105 Kentucky newcomers from the 2020 through 2025 classes, the advertised fee alone explained 70.6% of the variation in the first-crop weanling index, and adding the first book’s CI raised that to 74.5%. The fee carries the race record, pedigree and farm support with it, so the model cannot say which of those buyers are paying for.

In plain terms, a first crop sells largely on the price the farm put on the stallion. By the second crop, buyers are pricing the stallion himself.

Among 68 sires from the 2020 through 2024 classes with enough sales in both their first and second crops, the median stallion retained just 46% of his original market-relative weanling index. The quality of the first book did not predict how much he would retain.

Authentic opened at $75,000 with the strongest first book in the 2021 class, a CI of 3.06, and his first weanlings fetched 5.11 times the market median. His next three crops indexed at 3.00, 0.60 and 0.27, and he stands for $15,000 in 2027. Essential Quality’s first book was rated 2.87 and his weanlings ran 7.00, 3.33, 0.73 and 0.50. Charlatan’s was 3.53 and his ran 4.38, 1.67, 0.15 and 0.20. All three had mares most new stallions never see, and all three were selling weanlings below the market median by their third crop.

Figure 5 · The second-crop markdown

Strong first books lost about as much ground as ordinary ones

Share of first-crop weanling index kept in the second crop, against first-book Comparable Index, 68 Kentucky first-season sires, 2020 to 2024 classes 68 sires. The median sire kept 46% of his first-crop index. Flightline: first book 6.98, kept 30%; Charlatan: first book 3.53, kept 38%; Life Is Good: first book 3.27, kept 46%; Authentic: first book 3.06, kept 59%; Essential Quality: first book 2.87, kept 48%; Forte: first book 2.54, kept 30%; Elite Power: first book 2.46, kept 31%; Cody's Wish: first book 2.45, kept 38%; Improbable: first book 2.39, kept 19%; Omaha Beach: first book 2.18, kept 52% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 1 1.5 2 3 5 7 First-book Comparable Index (log scale) kept 100% median sire kept 46% Catalina Cruiser (2020 entrant): first book 1.98, first crop 1.09, second crop 0.67, kept 62% Yoshida (2020 entrant): first book 1.69, first crop 0.78, second crop 0.17, kept 22% Audible (2020 entrant): first book 1.86, first crop 2.72, second crop 1.94, kept 71% Vino Rosso (2020 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.78, second crop 0.71, kept 40% Mitole (2020 entrant): first book 1.51, first crop 1.78, second crop 0.91, kept 51% World of Trouble (2020 entrant): first book 1.23, first crop 0.44, second crop 0.16, kept 36% Enticed (2020 entrant): first book 1.33, first crop 0.42, second crop 0.23, kept 55% Flameaway (2020 entrant): first book 1.30, first crop 0.84, second crop 0.21, kept 25% Maximus Mischief (2020 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 0.94, second crop 0.56, kept 60% Complexity (2021 entrant): first book 1.53, first crop 1.13, second crop 0.59, kept 52% Echo Town (2021 entrant): first book 1.34, first crop 0.59, second crop 0.88, kept 149% Game Winner (2021 entrant): first book 1.78, first crop 2.89, second crop 0.48, kept 17% Gift Box (2021 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 0.40, second crop 0.18, kept 45% Honor A. P. (2021 entrant): first book 1.28, first crop 1.00, second crop 0.30, kept 30% Instagrand (2021 entrant): first book 1.42, first crop 0.97, second crop 0.38, kept 39% Maximum Security (2021 entrant): first book 1.42, first crop 0.78, second crop 0.42, kept 54% Spun to Run (2021 entrant): first book 1.10, first crop 0.74, second crop 0.40, kept 54% Thousand Words (2021 entrant): first book 1.01, first crop 0.33, second crop 0.12, kept 36% Tiz the Law (2021 entrant): first book 1.68, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.68, kept 44% Tom's d'Etat (2021 entrant): first book 1.72, first crop 0.36, second crop 0.30, kept 83% Vekoma (2021 entrant): first book 1.55, first crop 1.67, second crop 1.25, kept 75% Volatile (2021 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.47, second crop 0.96, kept 65% Beau Liam (2022 entrant): first book 1.18, first crop 0.57, second crop 1.10, kept 193% Independence Hall (2022 entrant): first book 1.28, first crop 0.84, second crop 0.60, kept 71% Knicks Go (2022 entrant): first book 1.70, first crop 1.00, second crop 0.76, kept 76% Known Agenda (2022 entrant): first book 1.21, first crop 0.26, second crop 0.31, kept 119% Maxfield (2022 entrant): first book 1.89, first crop 2.75, second crop 1.72, kept 62% Modernist (2022 entrant): first book 1.02, first crop 0.28, second crop 0.09, kept 32% Rock Your World (2022 entrant): first book 1.20, first crop 0.50, second crop 0.24, kept 48% Tacitus (2022 entrant): first book 1.41, first crop 0.81, second crop 0.72, kept 89% Yaupon (2022 entrant): first book 1.55, first crop 2.44, second crop 1.33, kept 55% Aloha West (2023 entrant): first book 1.13, first crop 0.40, second crop 0.08, kept 20% Corniche (2023 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 1.80, second crop 1.07, kept 59% Cyberknife (2023 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.31, kept 20% Drain the Clock (2023 entrant): first book 1.22, first crop 0.93, second crop 0.40, kept 43% Early Voting (2023 entrant): first book 1.66, first crop 1.69, second crop 0.73, kept 43% Epicenter (2023 entrant): first book 1.76, first crop 2.67, second crop 2.00, kept 75% Golden Pal (2023 entrant): first book 1.65, first crop 2.00, second crop 1.53, kept 76% Greatest Honour (2023 entrant): first book 1.06, first crop 0.43, second crop 0.08, kept 19% Jack Christopher (2023 entrant): first book 1.71, first crop 2.00, second crop 0.53, kept 26% Mandaloun (2023 entrant): first book 1.89, first crop 1.11, second crop 0.43, kept 39% Mo Donegal (2023 entrant): first book 1.32, first crop 0.56, second crop 0.15, kept 27% Mystic Guide (2023 entrant): first book 1.31, first crop 1.44, second crop 0.20, kept 14% Nashville (2023 entrant): first book 1.22, first crop 1.02, second crop 0.48, kept 47% Speaker's Corner (2023 entrant): first book 1.40, first crop 0.58, second crop 0.12, kept 21% Annapolis (2024 entrant): first book 1.46, first crop 0.67, second crop 0.16, kept 24% Arabian Lion (2024 entrant): first book 1.49, first crop 1.07, second crop 0.71, kept 66% Arcangelo (2024 entrant): first book 1.37, first crop 1.07, second crop 0.18, kept 17% Gunite (2024 entrant): first book 1.46, first crop 2.07, second crop 2.52, kept 122% Mage (2024 entrant): first book 1.60, first crop 1.47, second crop 0.55, kept 37% Pappacap (2024 entrant): first book 1.17, first crop 0.43, second crop 0.17, kept 40% Proxy (2024 entrant): first book 1.27, first crop 0.13, second crop 0.22, kept 169% Taiba (2024 entrant): first book 1.51, first crop 1.80, second crop 0.67, kept 37% Up to the Mark (2024 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.67, second crop 1.26, kept 75% Omaha Beach (2020 entrant): first book 2.18, first crop 3.33, second crop 1.74, kept 52% Authentic (2021 entrant): first book 3.06, first crop 5.11, second crop 3.00, kept 59% Improbable (2021 entrant): first book 2.39, first crop 2.28, second crop 0.44, kept 19% McKinzie (2021 entrant): first book 2.16, first crop 2.61, second crop 1.55, kept 59% War of Will (2021 entrant): first book 2.03, first crop 2.00, second crop 1.62, kept 81% Charlatan (2022 entrant): first book 3.53, first crop 4.38, second crop 1.67, kept 38% Essential Quality (2022 entrant): first book 2.87, first crop 7.00, second crop 3.33, kept 48% Flightline (2023 entrant): first book 6.98, first crop 11.11, second crop 3.33, kept 30% Jackie's Warrior (2023 entrant): first book 2.01, first crop 4.22, second crop 1.60, kept 38% Life Is Good (2023 entrant): first book 3.27, first crop 7.22, second crop 3.33, kept 46% Olympiad (2023 entrant): first book 2.16, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.27, kept 17% Cody's Wish (2024 entrant): first book 2.45, first crop 3.57, second crop 1.34, kept 38% Elite Power (2024 entrant): first book 2.46, first crop 2.27, second crop 0.71, kept 31% Forte (2024 entrant): first book 2.54, first crop 2.10, second crop 0.63, kept 30% Authentic Improbable War of Will Beau Liam Charlatan Essential Quality Flightline Life Is Good Gunite First book 2.00 or higher Below 2.00 Share of first-crop weanling index kept in the second crop, against first-book Comparable Index, 68 Kentucky first-season sires, 2020 to 2024 classes 68 sires. The median sire kept 46% of his first-crop index. Flightline: first book 6.98, kept 30%; Charlatan: first book 3.53, kept 38%; Life Is Good: first book 3.27, kept 46%; Authentic: first book 3.06, kept 59%; Essential Quality: first book 2.87, kept 48%; Forte: first book 2.54, kept 30%; Elite Power: first book 2.46, kept 31%; Cody's Wish: first book 2.45, kept 38%; Improbable: first book 2.39, kept 19%; Omaha Beach: first book 2.18, kept 52% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% 1 1.5 2 3 5 7 First-book Comparable Index (log scale) kept 100% median 46% Catalina Cruiser (2020 entrant): first book 1.98, first crop 1.09, second crop 0.67, kept 62% Yoshida (2020 entrant): first book 1.69, first crop 0.78, second crop 0.17, kept 22% Audible (2020 entrant): first book 1.86, first crop 2.72, second crop 1.94, kept 71% Vino Rosso (2020 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.78, second crop 0.71, kept 40% Mitole (2020 entrant): first book 1.51, first crop 1.78, second crop 0.91, kept 51% World of Trouble (2020 entrant): first book 1.23, first crop 0.44, second crop 0.16, kept 36% Enticed (2020 entrant): first book 1.33, first crop 0.42, second crop 0.23, kept 55% Flameaway (2020 entrant): first book 1.30, first crop 0.84, second crop 0.21, kept 25% Maximus Mischief (2020 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 0.94, second crop 0.56, kept 60% Complexity (2021 entrant): first book 1.53, first crop 1.13, second crop 0.59, kept 52% Echo Town (2021 entrant): first book 1.34, first crop 0.59, second crop 0.88, kept 149% Game Winner (2021 entrant): first book 1.78, first crop 2.89, second crop 0.48, kept 17% Gift Box (2021 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 0.40, second crop 0.18, kept 45% Honor A. P. (2021 entrant): first book 1.28, first crop 1.00, second crop 0.30, kept 30% Instagrand (2021 entrant): first book 1.42, first crop 0.97, second crop 0.38, kept 39% Maximum Security (2021 entrant): first book 1.42, first crop 0.78, second crop 0.42, kept 54% Spun to Run (2021 entrant): first book 1.10, first crop 0.74, second crop 0.40, kept 54% Thousand Words (2021 entrant): first book 1.01, first crop 0.33, second crop 0.12, kept 36% Tiz the Law (2021 entrant): first book 1.68, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.68, kept 44% Tom's d'Etat (2021 entrant): first book 1.72, first crop 0.36, second crop 0.30, kept 83% Vekoma (2021 entrant): first book 1.55, first crop 1.67, second crop 1.25, kept 75% Volatile (2021 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.47, second crop 0.96, kept 65% Beau Liam (2022 entrant): first book 1.18, first crop 0.57, second crop 1.10, kept 193% Independence Hall (2022 entrant): first book 1.28, first crop 0.84, second crop 0.60, kept 71% Knicks Go (2022 entrant): first book 1.70, first crop 1.00, second crop 0.76, kept 76% Known Agenda (2022 entrant): first book 1.21, first crop 0.26, second crop 0.31, kept 119% Maxfield (2022 entrant): first book 1.89, first crop 2.75, second crop 1.72, kept 62% Modernist (2022 entrant): first book 1.02, first crop 0.28, second crop 0.09, kept 32% Rock Your World (2022 entrant): first book 1.20, first crop 0.50, second crop 0.24, kept 48% Tacitus (2022 entrant): first book 1.41, first crop 0.81, second crop 0.72, kept 89% Yaupon (2022 entrant): first book 1.55, first crop 2.44, second crop 1.33, kept 55% Aloha West (2023 entrant): first book 1.13, first crop 0.40, second crop 0.08, kept 20% Corniche (2023 entrant): first book 1.25, first crop 1.80, second crop 1.07, kept 59% Cyberknife (2023 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.31, kept 20% Drain the Clock (2023 entrant): first book 1.22, first crop 0.93, second crop 0.40, kept 43% Early Voting (2023 entrant): first book 1.66, first crop 1.69, second crop 0.73, kept 43% Epicenter (2023 entrant): first book 1.76, first crop 2.67, second crop 2.00, kept 75% Golden Pal (2023 entrant): first book 1.65, first crop 2.00, second crop 1.53, kept 76% Greatest Honour (2023 entrant): first book 1.06, first crop 0.43, second crop 0.08, kept 19% Jack Christopher (2023 entrant): first book 1.71, first crop 2.00, second crop 0.53, kept 26% Mandaloun (2023 entrant): first book 1.89, first crop 1.11, second crop 0.43, kept 39% Mo Donegal (2023 entrant): first book 1.32, first crop 0.56, second crop 0.15, kept 27% Mystic Guide (2023 entrant): first book 1.31, first crop 1.44, second crop 0.20, kept 14% Nashville (2023 entrant): first book 1.22, first crop 1.02, second crop 0.48, kept 47% Speaker's Corner (2023 entrant): first book 1.40, first crop 0.58, second crop 0.12, kept 21% Annapolis (2024 entrant): first book 1.46, first crop 0.67, second crop 0.16, kept 24% Arabian Lion (2024 entrant): first book 1.49, first crop 1.07, second crop 0.71, kept 66% Arcangelo (2024 entrant): first book 1.37, first crop 1.07, second crop 0.18, kept 17% Gunite (2024 entrant): first book 1.46, first crop 2.07, second crop 2.52, kept 122% Mage (2024 entrant): first book 1.60, first crop 1.47, second crop 0.55, kept 37% Pappacap (2024 entrant): first book 1.17, first crop 0.43, second crop 0.17, kept 40% Proxy (2024 entrant): first book 1.27, first crop 0.13, second crop 0.22, kept 169% Taiba (2024 entrant): first book 1.51, first crop 1.80, second crop 0.67, kept 37% Up to the Mark (2024 entrant): first book 1.57, first crop 1.67, second crop 1.26, kept 75% Omaha Beach (2020 entrant): first book 2.18, first crop 3.33, second crop 1.74, kept 52% Authentic (2021 entrant): first book 3.06, first crop 5.11, second crop 3.00, kept 59% Improbable (2021 entrant): first book 2.39, first crop 2.28, second crop 0.44, kept 19% McKinzie (2021 entrant): first book 2.16, first crop 2.61, second crop 1.55, kept 59% War of Will (2021 entrant): first book 2.03, first crop 2.00, second crop 1.62, kept 81% Charlatan (2022 entrant): first book 3.53, first crop 4.38, second crop 1.67, kept 38% Essential Quality (2022 entrant): first book 2.87, first crop 7.00, second crop 3.33, kept 48% Flightline (2023 entrant): first book 6.98, first crop 11.11, second crop 3.33, kept 30% Jackie's Warrior (2023 entrant): first book 2.01, first crop 4.22, second crop 1.60, kept 38% Life Is Good (2023 entrant): first book 3.27, first crop 7.22, second crop 3.33, kept 46% Olympiad (2023 entrant): first book 2.16, first crop 1.56, second crop 0.27, kept 17% Cody's Wish (2024 entrant): first book 2.45, first crop 3.57, second crop 1.34, kept 38% Elite Power (2024 entrant): first book 2.46, first crop 2.27, second crop 0.71, kept 31% Forte (2024 entrant): first book 2.54, first crop 2.10, second crop 0.63, kept 30% Authentic War of Will Beau Liam Flightline First book 2.00 or higher Below 2.00
Kentucky first-season sires of 2020 to 2024 with an index for both their first and second crops. Each dot is one sire; green marks first books of 2.00 or higher.
First-book CI, 2020 and 2021 entrantsStallions2027 fee of $50,000+No longer on Kentucky roster
Below 1.5019012
1.50 to 1.991225
2.00 or higher623

In the 2020 and 2021 classes, none of the nineteen stallions with a first book below 1.50 reached $50,000, and twelve have left Kentucky. Tiz the Law and Vekoma got there from the middle group and Omaha Beach and McKinzie from the top, while Improbable, Catholic Boy and War of Will opened above 2.00 and are gone.

Across the 2020 through 2024 classes, fifteen newcomers with enough weanling sales to index opened with first books of 2.00 or better. Five stand for $50,000 or more in 2027: Omaha Beach, McKinzie, Flightline, Life Is Good and Cody’s Wish. Seven stand for less and three have left the state. No stallion in those classes reached $50,000 from a first book below 1.50, and a strong one got there one time in three.

The strong books that recovered did it in the third crop, once runners reached the track. McKinzie went from 2.61 to 1.55 and back to 3.33. Life Is Good and Flightline, the strongest first books of 2023, recovered in their third crops this November, although several of those medians rest on three to eight sales.

What the Breeder Actually Has to Make Back

An auction index measures price against the market. A breeder also has to cover the stud fee, the board and the cost of getting the foal to the sale. University of Kentucky researchers Jenna Bryant and C. Jill Stowe studied 74,789 yearlings that sold at Keeneland and Fasig-Tipton from 2001 through 2018. After advertised stud fees, a commission and modeled production costs, 44.4% of those sales cleared their lower-cost profitability threshold and 36.1% the higher one. By stallions at $100,000 or more, 57.6% cleared the lower threshold; at $5,000 to $9,999, 28.1%; below $5,000, 19.7%.

We ran a related test on the 2026 Keeneland September catalog. For each yearling with a known conception fee, we took the sale price, deducted a 5% commission and the advertised fee, and asked whether at least $20,000 or $35,000 remained for production. A buyback or withdrawal produced no sale at that auction, so our denominator is every cataloged horse with a known fee, where the earlier study counted only horses that sold.

Sire’s conception feeKeeneland September 2026 catalogedShare clearing $20,000 costShare clearing $35,000 cost
$5,000 to $9,99913223%15%
$10,000 to $14,99930128%17%
$15,000 to $24,99941839%31%
$25,000 to $49,9991,65740%36%
$50,000 to $99,99996338%36%
$100,000+60651%50%

Most of the cataloged yearlings did not clear even the $20,000 hurdle. Among the 3,038 by sires standing from $15,000 through $99,999, the share clearing the $20,000 production-cost test ranged from 38% to 40%, despite the very different stud fees. The $100,000-plus group reached 51%; the $5,000-to-$9,999 group managed 23%. Fasig-Tipton October 2025 produced a similar ranking, with the middle fee tiers between 32% and 34% on the lower-cost assumption.

These are modeled hurdles. The cost assumptions are in 2018 dollars, so today’s test is generous, and the 12% of the catalog with no identifiable conception fee likely flatters the cheaper sires. A breeder who owns the farm, supplies the labor or breeds to race works with different economics.

For the breeder who needs to sell the yearling, choosing a $25,000 season instead of a $75,000 one did little to improve the proportion of cataloged yearlings clearing the modeled cost hurdle.

Put in dollars, a Sovereignty yearling has to bring about $179,000 just to clear the modest $20,000 hurdle, more than twice this year’s Keeneland September median of $85,000. Englishman’s needs about $73,700.

For a stallion’s second through fourth seasons, a foal share is one way to cut the cash at risk. The breeder pays less up front and gives the stallion owner an agreed interest in the foal or its sale proceeds, so the farm shares a disappointing result and the breeder gives up some upside. We have no reliable count of these arrangements in Kentucky, and the terms vary too much to generalize.

November Has Started Sorting the Next Generations

Of 73 stallions in the seven historical classes with a first-crop weanling index below 1.25, none stands for $50,000 or more in Kentucky in 2027. Thirteen of the 63 that began above 1.25 do.

The 2025 stud-entry class has just had its first November weanling sales. Seven of the fourteen commercially represented stallions cleared 1.25, using a combined Keeneland and Fasig-Tipton median of $63,500. National Treasure led at 3.03 with 22 sold, Muth followed at 2.83 on fifteen, Arabian Knight registered 1.93 on thirty-six and Domestic Product 1.81 on thirty-four. Prince of Monaco, Dornoch and Cogburn also cleared the line.

2025 stud entrantFirst-crop weanling indexSold in the two November sales2027 fee
National Treasure3.0322$30,000
Muth2.8315$25,000
Arabian Knight1.9336$30,000
Domestic Product1.8134$20,000
Prince of Monaco1.5727$15,000
Dornoch1.548$20,000
Cogburn1.5015$20,000
Kingsbarns1.1829$17,500
Gun Pilot1.1019$12,500
Seize the Grey0.9427$20,000
Newgate0.9419$10,000
Charge It0.7626$10,000
Blazing Sevens0.5015$10,000
Timberlake0.3111$10,000

At Keeneland, Muth brought a $180,000 median on fifteen sold, and National Treasure $170,000 on nineteen. Fourteen of Muth’s thirty-three cataloged weanlings were withdrawn, along with thirteen of National Treasure’s thirty-seven. Arabian Knight had twenty-two withdrawals from sixty-five cataloged but still led the class in Keeneland gross at $5.05 million. Domestic Product’s offering was spread through all five books, and thirty of his thirty-six offered foals sold in the ring. A high median from a selectively presented group and demand sustained across an entire offering are both worth knowing before booking a mare.

I have a stake in this class. Our Domestic Product colt brought $330,000 at Keeneland, the top price for any Domestic Product weanling this year, and our Arabian Knight filly brought $150,000. We kept our National Treasure to sell in January.

I’ll make a forecast from that evidence. By 2031, I expect one or two of these fourteen commercial 2025 entrants to stand in Kentucky for at least $50,000, and I expect them to come from the seven that opened above 1.25. That gives the class the same span the 2021 entrants have had to reach the 2027 roster. We can grade the call when the fees are announced.

Kentucky’s 2024 entrants had 393 first-crop weanlings cataloged at Keeneland in 2025 and just 171 second-crop weanlings this year, a 56.5% decline. Forte’s median fell from $160,000 to $40,000, Elite Power’s from $170,000 to $45,000, Taiba’s from $125,000 to $40,000 and Cody’s Wish’s from $200,000 to $90,000. The class’s second-crop median was $37,500, 1.25 times the original conception fee. Gunite was an exception with a combined-November index of 2.52, although only seven sales supported it.

The 2023 entrants have their first two-year-olds on the track, and the spread is enormous. Life Is Good indexed at 5.35 on eleven sold and Flightline at 3.86 on five, while Jack Christopher was at 0.16 on seven, Cyberknife 0.11 on five and Epicenter 0.09 on seven. Golden Pal and Jackie’s Warrior each reached 1.57. The samples are small and the gap is still plain. From the 2022 class, Yaupon’s fourth crop indexed at 2.48 on thirty sold and Maxfield’s at 1.94 on fourteen; both have sons entering stud next spring.

Seven Newcomers, a Bigger Price Tag and the Same Mares

All twenty newcomers now have announced fees, including Stronghold at Walmac for $10,000.

Incoming 2027 stallionSireKentucky farmIntroductory fee
SovereigntyInto MischiefDarley$150,000
NysosNyquistAshford$80,000
KnightsbridgeNyquistDarley$75,000
MagnitudeNot This TimeAshford$70,000
JournalismCurlinAshford$60,000
Ted NoffeyInto MischiefSpendthrift$60,000
EnglishmanMaxfieldLane’s End$50,000
BaezaMcKinzieSpendthrift$25,000
DeterministicLiam’s MapLane’s End$25,000
BrantGun RunnerHill ’n’ Dale$20,000
PaladinGun RunnerAshford$20,000
White AbarrioRace DayGainesway$17,500
Tappan StreetInto MischiefWinStar$15,000
Bishops BayUncle MoTaylor Made$12,500
Local KnowledgeYauponSpendthrift$12,500
Saudi CrownAlways DreamingDarby Dan$12,500
Hit ShowCandy Ride (ARG)Lane’s End$10,000
StrongholdGhostzapperWalmac$10,000
ColloquialVekomaAirdrie$7,500
OttinhoQuality RoadThree Chimneys$7,500

Ten of the new horses are sons of stallions from the commercial classes we examined, including Maxfield and Yaupon from the younger groups. Englishman starts at $50,000 beside Maxfield’s $75,000, Baeza at $25,000 against McKinzie’s $50,000, and Local Knowledge at $12,500 against Yaupon’s $100,000. That is a familiar way for breeders to access a fashionable sire line at a lower price, while making a fresh bet on the son.

Twelve of the twenty newcomers trace through three paternal branches: four each through Storm Cat, Uncle Mo and Candy Ride. Into Mischief and Not This Time represent the Storm Cat branch; Nyquist, Yaupon and Uncle Mo the Uncle Mo branch; and Gun Runner, Vekoma and Candy Ride the Candy Ride branch. These are commercial sire-line relationships, rather than a measure of genomic diversity.

Those sons will need good mares, and Japanese buyers want the same families. At Keeneland September 2026, buyers paid $83.5 million for fifty-three colts at $1 million or more. Two months later, Japan-based buyers spent $24.475 million on seventeen fillies and mares at Fasig-Tipton November, 27.7% of the sale’s fillies-and-mares gross, including twelve of the thirty-three that brought $1 million or more. Their share ran between 13.7% and 18.4% from 2017 through 2020 and between 27.7% and 32.2% in each of the last four Novembers, according to TI’s sale analysis.

Figure 6 · Where the mares went

Japan-based buyers took 27.7% to 32.2% of the fillies-and-mares gross in each of the last four Novembers

Japan-based buyers’ share of fillies-and-mares gross at Fasig-Tipton November, 2017 to 2026 2017: 18.4%; 2018: 15.7%; 2019: 18.3%; 2020: 13.7%; 2021: 33.4%; 2022: 17.6%; 2023: 28.5%; 2024: 32.2%; 2025: 28.0%; 2026: 27.7% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 2017: Japan-based buyers 18.4% of fillies-and-mares gross 18.4% 2017 2018: Japan-based buyers 15.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 15.7% 2018 2019: Japan-based buyers 18.3% of fillies-and-mares gross 18.3% 2019 2020: Japan-based buyers 13.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 13.7% 2020 2021: Japan-based buyers 33.4% of fillies-and-mares gross 33.4% 2021 2022: Japan-based buyers 17.6% of fillies-and-mares gross 17.6% 2022 2023: Japan-based buyers 28.5% of fillies-and-mares gross 28.5% 2023 2024: Japan-based buyers 32.2% of fillies-and-mares gross; leading buyer Grand Stud (through Narvick) 32.2% 2024 2025: Japan-based buyers 28.0% of fillies-and-mares gross 28.0% 2025 2026: Japan-based buyers 27.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 27.7% 2026 Japan-based buyers’ share of fillies-and-mares gross at Fasig-Tipton November, 2017 to 2026 2017: 18.4%; 2018: 15.7%; 2019: 18.3%; 2020: 13.7%; 2021: 33.4%; 2022: 17.6%; 2023: 28.5%; 2024: 32.2%; 2025: 28.0%; 2026: 27.7% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 2017: Japan-based buyers 18.4% of fillies-and-mares gross 18% ’17 2018: Japan-based buyers 15.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 16% ’18 2019: Japan-based buyers 18.3% of fillies-and-mares gross 18% ’19 2020: Japan-based buyers 13.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 14% ’20 2021: Japan-based buyers 33.4% of fillies-and-mares gross 33% ’21 2022: Japan-based buyers 17.6% of fillies-and-mares gross 18% ’22 2023: Japan-based buyers 28.5% of fillies-and-mares gross 28% ’23 2024: Japan-based buyers 32.2% of fillies-and-mares gross; leading buyer Grand Stud (through Narvick) 32% ’24 2025: Japan-based buyers 28.0% of fillies-and-mares gross 28% ’25 2026: Japan-based buyers 27.7% of fillies-and-mares gross 28% ’26
Fillies and mares sold at Fasig-Tipton November, by gross. Green marks the four most recent sales.

Mike Repole called the scale of Japanese buying devastating to American breeding after the sale. I understand the sentiment. The Japanese buyers have been smart and persistent participants in this market for decades, and they are doing what the free market allows. Repole has bought at Japanese sales himself. We spend millions upon millions chasing the next great stallion and let the mares he would need leave the country. If we want to keep our mares, we should buy them. In a forthcoming article I’ll look at which families are going and what their absence means for the American breeding pool.

A Game of Musical Chairs

Kentucky does not have enough good mares to give its twenty-three established $50,000-plus stallions and seven new ones the books they are used to. Something has to give: smaller books, weaker mares, or both.

Kentucky stallions advertised at $50,000 or more covered 3,580 mares in 2025. The nine newcomers opening at that price or higher from 2021 through 2024 drew first books of 152 to 229 mares, with a median of 192. If the seven premium 2027 newcomers cover a similar number, they will need 1,064 to 1,603 mares among them, roughly 30% to 45% of the entire 2025 premium-fee business. The premium pool can grow, as it did from 2,681 mares in 2020, but I suspect it grew largely by pulling mares up from cheaper stallions, which is part of why those books have weakened.

There are only so many breeders with the mares, budgets and appetite to pay $50,000 or more. A breeder who goes to Nysos or Magnitude might otherwise have booked an established sire at the same price, or may be stretching up from the $25,000 tier. The big farms will work hard to recruit those mares, but they also have established horses and second-, third- and fourth-season stallions whose books need filling. This is a game of musical chairs. I expect some newcomers and some established $50,000-plus sires to have a difficult year, although these figures can’t tell us which ones.

The breeder faces the same squeeze from the other side. By the time the foal sells, the breeder will have carried the cost for two or three years, and the farm may already have revised the fee. A first book’s size offers little assurance about what its foals will bring.

I also expect the new premium horses to have a harder time attracting the quality of mares their predecessors enjoyed. Nine first-season stallions opening at $50,000 or more from 2021 through 2024 had a median first-book Comparable Index of 2.87, meaning their mares’ foals by other stallions had earned almost three times as much as the average runner. Across 115 Kentucky first books of 50 or more mares from 2020 through 2025, that index has declined at comparable advertised fees. I expect the median first-book CI of the seven 2027 premium newcomers to be below 2.87.

The model behind that call measures the decline. We fitted the CI of those 115 first books against the stallion’s advertised fee and the season he entered stud. Fee and year together account for 72.5% of the variation. Hold the fee constant and first-book CI has fallen about 3.9% a year, with a 95% confidence range of 2.1% to 5.6%, and the decline holds after allowing for book size and for the share of unraced mares. Books for established Kentucky stallions have drifted down too, about 2.2% a year across 777 books. The premium first books held up through 2023, at medians of 3.06, 3.20 and 3.27 from 2021, then fell to 2.46 for Cody’s Wish, Elite Power and Forte in 2024.

Applied to the seven 2027 fees, the model projects first books from 1.84 for Englishman to 2.76 for Sovereignty, with a median of 2.08. Expensive first books have historically beaten that model, by a median of about 18%, and allowing for that puts the class median near 2.4. Both readings sit below 2.87.

Figure 7 · The forecast

All seven 2027 newcomers are projected to draw lower-rated first books than the 2.87 median of the 2021 to 2024 newcomers

First-book Comparable Index: nine Kentucky debuts at $50,000 or more, 2021 to 2024, and the model projection for the seven 2027 debuts Actual: Flightline 6.98; Charlatan 3.53; Life Is Good 3.27; Authentic 3.06; Essential Quality 2.87; Forte 2.54; Elite Power 2.46; Cody's Wish 2.45; Jackie's Warrior 2.01. Projected for 2027: Sovereignty 2.76; Nysos 2.19; Knightsbridge 2.14; Magnitude 2.08; Journalism 1.97; Ted Noffey 1.97; Englishman 1.84. 2021 to 2024 median 2.87; projected 2027 median 2.08, near 2.4 after allowing for the amount expensive first books have historically beaten the model. A Comparable Index of 1.00 means mares of average quality. NEWCOMERS OF 2021 TO 2024: ACTUAL Flightline, 2023, $200,000 Flightline: debuted 2023 at $200,000; first book CI 6.98 6.98 Charlatan, 2022, $50,000 Charlatan: debuted 2022 at $50,000; first book CI 3.53 3.53 Life Is Good, 2023, $100,000 Life Is Good: debuted 2023 at $100,000; first book CI 3.27 3.27 Authentic, 2021, $75,000 Authentic: debuted 2021 at $75,000; first book CI 3.06 3.06 Essential Quality, 2022, $75,000 Essential Quality: debuted 2022 at $75,000; first book CI 2.87 2.87 Forte, 2024, $50,000 Forte: debuted 2024 at $50,000; first book CI 2.54 2.54 Elite Power, 2024, $50,000 Elite Power: debuted 2024 at $50,000; first book CI 2.46 2.46 Cody's Wish, 2024, $75,000 Cody's Wish: debuted 2024 at $75,000; first book CI 2.45 2.45 Jackie's Warrior, 2023, $50,000 Jackie's Warrior: debuted 2023 at $50,000; first book CI 2.01 2.01 2027 NEWCOMERS: PROJECTED Sovereignty, $150,000 Sovereignty: debuts 2027 at $150,000; projected first book CI 2.76 from fee and entry year 2.76 Nysos, $80,000 Nysos: debuts 2027 at $80,000; projected first book CI 2.19 from fee and entry year 2.19 Knightsbridge, $75,000 Knightsbridge: debuts 2027 at $75,000; projected first book CI 2.14 from fee and entry year 2.14 Magnitude, $70,000 Magnitude: debuts 2027 at $70,000; projected first book CI 2.08 from fee and entry year 2.08 Journalism, $60,000 Journalism: debuts 2027 at $60,000; projected first book CI 1.97 from fee and entry year 1.97 Ted Noffey, $60,000 Ted Noffey: debuts 2027 at $60,000; projected first book CI 1.97 from fee and entry year 1.97 Englishman, $50,000 Englishman: debuts 2027 at $50,000; projected first book CI 1.84 from fee and entry year 1.84 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 2.87, the 2021–2024 median First-book Comparable Index (1.00 = average mares) First-book Comparable Index: nine Kentucky debuts at $50,000 or more, 2021 to 2024, and the model projection for the seven 2027 debuts Actual: Flightline 6.98; Charlatan 3.53; Life Is Good 3.27; Authentic 3.06; Essential Quality 2.87; Forte 2.54; Elite Power 2.46; Cody's Wish 2.45; Jackie's Warrior 2.01. Projected for 2027: Sovereignty 2.76; Nysos 2.19; Knightsbridge 2.14; Magnitude 2.08; Journalism 1.97; Ted Noffey 1.97; Englishman 1.84. 2021 to 2024 median 2.87; projected 2027 median 2.08, near 2.4 after allowing for the amount expensive first books have historically beaten the model. A Comparable Index of 1.00 means mares of average quality. NEWCOMERS OF 2021 TO 2024: ACTUAL Flightline, 2023, $200,000 Flightline: debuted 2023 at $200,000; first book CI 6.98 6.98 Charlatan, 2022, $50,000 Charlatan: debuted 2022 at $50,000; first book CI 3.53 3.53 Life Is Good, 2023, $100,000 Life Is Good: debuted 2023 at $100,000; first book CI 3.27 3.27 Authentic, 2021, $75,000 Authentic: debuted 2021 at $75,000; first book CI 3.06 3.06 Essential Quality, 2022, $75,000 Essential Quality: debuted 2022 at $75,000; first book CI 2.87 2.87 Forte, 2024, $50,000 Forte: debuted 2024 at $50,000; first book CI 2.54 2.54 Elite Power, 2024, $50,000 Elite Power: debuted 2024 at $50,000; first book CI 2.46 2.46 Cody's Wish, 2024, $75,000 Cody's Wish: debuted 2024 at $75,000; first book CI 2.45 2.45 Jackie's Warrior, 2023, $50,000 Jackie's Warrior: debuted 2023 at $50,000; first book CI 2.01 2.01 2027 NEWCOMERS: PROJECTED Sovereignty, $150,000 Sovereignty: debuts 2027 at $150,000; projected first book CI 2.76 from fee and entry year 2.76 Nysos, $80,000 Nysos: debuts 2027 at $80,000; projected first book CI 2.19 from fee and entry year 2.19 Knightsbridge, $75,000 Knightsbridge: debuts 2027 at $75,000; projected first book CI 2.14 from fee and entry year 2.14 Magnitude, $70,000 Magnitude: debuts 2027 at $70,000; projected first book CI 2.08 from fee and entry year 2.08 Journalism, $60,000 Journalism: debuts 2027 at $60,000; projected first book CI 1.97 from fee and entry year 1.97 Ted Noffey, $60,000 Ted Noffey: debuts 2027 at $60,000; projected first book CI 1.97 from fee and entry year 1.97 Englishman, $50,000 Englishman: debuts 2027 at $50,000; projected first book CI 1.84 from fee and entry year 1.84 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 2.87, the 2021–2024 median First-book Comparable Index (1.00 = average mares)
Each bar is a stallion’s first-book Comparable Index: how much the foals of the mares he covered in his first season have earned by other stallions, against the average runner. 1.00 is average; 2.00 means those foals earned twice as much. Gray bars are the actual first books of the nine Kentucky newcomers that opened at $50,000 or more from 2021 through 2024. Green bars are the model’s projections for the seven 2027 newcomers at $50,000 or more, based on their fees and the yearly decline; allowing for the amount expensive first books have historically beaten the model puts the class median near 2.4.

Before putting my name on that forecast, we tried to break it. We loosened the assumptions, left out Flightline’s outsized book, left out each big farm and each year one at a time, and asked the model to predict seasons it had never seen. Every time, it still pointed below 2.87. The one assumption that breaks it is the decline itself. TI’s research file records each test.

With seven horses, the class median is the fourth-best book, so the forecast comes true if four of the seven fall short of 2.87. Three of them, Nysos, Magnitude and Journalism, stand at Ashford, and Ashford’s first books have come in below what their fees would predict. Its ten first books of 50 or more mares in this period ran 14.5% under the model, and the best of them was Epicenter’s 1.76 at $45,000. If the three Ashford horses fall short, only one of Knightsbridge, Ted Noffey and Englishman has to join them, and Sovereignty’s book won’t change the answer.

A major farm’s own mares can change the outcome. Godolphin owns Sovereignty and Knightsbridge, and its mares gave Essential Quality a 2.87 first book and Cody’s Wish 2.45. And if the decline in mare quality stops, the call becomes a coin flip. Seven books is a small sample, and CI moves as the mares’ other foals race. I’ll grade that prediction when BloodHorse publishes its 2027 Quality of Mares Bred figures.

So What Should a Breeder Do?

The second half of the question I kept hearing has the simpler answer. Anywhere from $15,000 to $99,999, about four in ten yearlings cataloged at Keeneland September this year cleared the $20,000 production-cost test. Paying more inside that range did not improve the odds. It buys a different mating, and the mare has to justify it.

For the first half, the evidence points to timing. A newcomer pays his first-crop breeders: even the stallions that later left Kentucky sold their first weanlings near the market. The risk sits in the seasons that follow. A second season is booked before a single foal has sold, and the median sire then keeps 46% of his first-crop index. I’d treat the first season as the cleanest version of the bet and price the second, third and fourth as if the markdown is coming. That is where a foal share or a reduced fee earns its keep.

By the third season the ring has given its first verdict. No stallion in seven classes reached $50,000 from a first-crop index below 1.25, and a strong first book did nothing to protect the second crop. I’d let November decide whether a mare goes back to him.

For the seven premium newcomers of 2027, the scarce thing is the mare. Their farms need 1,064 to 1,603 of them from a premium pool that covered 3,580 in 2025, and I expect their books to be weaker than their predecessors’. A breeder with the kind of mare those books lack has leverage this winter and should use it.


About the analysis. Breeding counts come from The Jockey Club’s Reports of Mares Bred (2026 preliminary, through November 13) and TI’s stallion-fee files. The cohort is every stallion that entered stud from 2015 through 2021 with at least fifteen first-crop horses cataloged at Keeneland September and November and Fasig-Tipton October and November. Status is measured against TI’s November 10, 2026 Kentucky fee roster, using documented fees where a farm publishes none, as Three Chimneys does for Gun Runner; Stronghold’s $10,000 is from Walmac’s 2027 announcement. The 110 departures were traced through Jockey Club reports and farm and press records, and eight remain unresolved. Book quality is BloodHorse’s Comparable Index from its 2020 through 2025 Quality of Mares Bred tables, weighted by mares, for Kentucky books of twenty or more; each year’s CI depends on the earnings available at its report date. A sire needs at least three sold weanlings for a crop index. Groups defined by 2027 status are hindsight groupings and do not show cause and effect. The first-book forecast regresses log CI on log fee and entry year; TI’s research file holds the projections, sensitivity tests and backtests, and the data and model specifications are available on request. The Japan-based share uses published buyers and documented principals against TI’s Fasig-Tipton November results population (80 mares and prospects, $88,365,000).

Corrections. Every figure in this piece was checked against its source, and an error is still possible. If you find one, let me know through our contact form or @TB_Intel on X, and I’ll correct it quickly.